1 of 3,910

A mother’s promise by Renee Salt with Kate Thompson: the mother who outwitted Mengele to


A Mother’s Promise by Renee Salt with Kate Thompson (Seven Dials £20, 304pp) 

Never again’ was the world’s solemn vow, after the unspeakable horror of what the Nazis called ‘the final solution’ – the genocide of the Jewish people – was at last known. Yet ‘never again’ rings hollowly at a time when anti-Semitism is on the increase and Jews are being starved in brutal captivity by Islamist terrorists.

Renia after the war as a young mother with her own little daughter

Renia after the war as a young mother with her own little daughter

That is why we need the testimonies of those able still to remind us what happened in the Holocaust. Coming so soon after thousands of candles were lit on January 27 for those murdered, A Mother’s Promise by Renee Salt is deeply moving and essential reading.

Renee was born Rywka (or Renia) Berkowicz in Poland in 1929. Her family was prosperous, middle-class, elegant, cultured; the little girl loved the lavish family gatherings in an area where Jews, Poles and Germans lived peaceably side by side. That is, until 1935, when rumblings of Jew-hatred began. By 1939, the warm extended-family celebrations would stop.

Right at the beginning of her story, before the details of oppression and suffering begin, Renia establishes what she stands for: ‘I am 95 years old at the time of writing and I am a witness to history… a survivor of the Holocaust, and this book is my attempt to make sense of a story which, at times, I can scarcely believe happened to me. But it did… Some of the pages that follow are drenched in horror but, every so often, a little light of hope and humanity shines out. There is love, too, believe me, so much love.’

Thank goodness for those simple words, because Renia’s story – like so many other Holocaust memoirs, from Eli Wiesel to Edith Eger – leaves faith in humanity teetering on the edge of an abyss. When the Nazis invaded Poland, Renia’s family, like all the others, lost everything; the synagogues were closed or destroyed and Jews were stripped of all their rights, and, with terrifying speed, Renia’s family, like thousands of others, was forced into the ghetto. Here it’s essential to praise the powerful structure of this book, which adds so greatly to its cumulative effect. Throughout, Renia’s recollections are printed in italics, and between those passages the writer Kate Thompson provides an excellent, beautifully written historical narrative, setting Renia’s story in context as well as distilling many of their personal conversations. The trust and affection between the two women gives every page extraordinary emotional depth.

Holocaust survivor Renee Salt with Kate Thompson

Holocaust survivor Renee Salt with Kate Thompson 

Eight of her family were living in one room in the horrendously overcrowded and squalid Zdunska Wold ghetto when 11-year-old Renia was forced to work long hours in a factory making garments for the German army. But starvation, exhaustion and terror were nothing compared with the unforgettable horror of seeing

her little sister snatched away

by the Nazis, one of several hundred other children taken to the Kulmhof death camp and never seen again.

The agonies pile up: a ten-hour journey in a stifling cattle truck to the Lodz ghetto, overcrowding, the desperate scrabble for half a cabbage, ‘terror alternating with tedium’. Then, when Renia is 15, the transports to Auschwitz begin.

In the darkness of the cattle truck, Renia was comforted to be with her parents, and ‘tried to concentrate on the feeling of holding my mother’s hand in mind. It was like holding on to life.’ But, on arrival, Renia watches her beloved father jump down from the train – and disappear from her life forever.

Bewildered Renia and her mother Sala shuffle forward in the queue for selection, not knowing that the ‘shiny boots’ of the SS man at the top belong to the notorious Dr Josef Mengele. He directs those who look unfit for work to the left, to die immediately. Mother and daughter clutch hands, but Renia is sent to the right and her mother to the left. Then a miracle. Renia’s mother has already lost one daughter and isn’t going to let it happen again, so she darts to Renia’s side – and gets away with it. To this day Renia cannot fathom how.

Existence in the hell-hole of Auschwitz should by now be known to every decent person. The unbearable cold, bare feet and hands, rags to wear, lice, starvation, beatings, slave labour, stink, death… through it all Sala keeps her daughter going. Her devotion ‘offered her a reason to live’. But Sala is injured, ill and weak, and when they are both transported to Bergen-Belsen, they are separated in the chaos. After two days of searching the camp, Renia finds her mother, barely alive, and hears her whispered instruction, ‘Do not cry when I die.’ Ten days after British troops liberate the camp, Sala Berkowicz dies at the age of 42, one of an estimated 14,000 there for whom the end of the war came too late.

Renia’s own plunge into near-death illness, her recovery, gradual discovery that some of her extended family were still alive, and the most wonderful, extraordinary love story leading to life in England… all this keeps you on the edge of your seat with pity, horror and excitement.

I don’t want to give spoilers away because I want you to read this beautiful, uplifting testimony. But one depressing fact is worth noting: two or three times during her work as a Holocaust educator, Renia Salt has actually been challenged by students who told her she was wrong – and the whole thing never happened.



Read More

Leave a comment