Panic as home values plummet in half of the biggest US cities
Nearly half of America’s biggest cities are now seeing home prices fall — a sign that cracks are spreading through the once-booming housing market.
Across the US, the cost of a single-family home rose just 1.5 percent in August compared with a year earlier, according to the S&P Cotality Case-Shiller index.
That marks a slowdown from July’s 1.7 percent increase — and the weakest annual growth since 2023, when soaring mortgage rates and poor affordability briefly sent prices into reverse.
Of the 20 major metros tracked by Case-Shiller, nine recorded outright price declines, while 13 rose more slowly than the national average.
‘August’s data shows US home prices continuing to slow,’ Nicholas Godec, head of fixed income tradables and commodities at S&P Dow Jones Indices, told Realtor.com.
‘For the fourth straight month, home values have lost ground to inflation, meaning homeowners are seeing their real wealth decline even as nominal prices inch higher.’
Florida and Texas were hit hardest. Tampa saw the steepest drop — down 3.3 percent year-on-year — and has now notched 10 straight months of falling prices.
The city, along with others across Florida, is now officially a buyer’s markets.
In Tampa, home prices have been dropping for 10 months straight. The city, along with several others in Florida, are now officially buyer’s markets (Pictured: Tampa)
Your browser does not support iframes.
Nicholas Godec, head of fixed income tradables and commodities at S&P Dow Jones Indices
A buyer’s market occurs when there are more homes for sale than buyers. This gives buyers leverage: they can negotiate lower prices, ask for concessions, and take their time finding the right property.
While a buyer’s market is obviously great news for buyers, it can be an ominous sign for the economy as a whole.
A buyer’s market can be an early warning sign of a cooling market, or even a housing market crash, because it usually indicates other economic struggles — such as affordability crises, high interest rates and weak consumer confidence.
Other Southern metros with steep declines were Miami (1.66 percent) and Dallas (1.19 percent), both of which are also buyer’s markets.
Housing markets in the Sun Belt and West are also cooling down — demand is slowing and prices are falling/not rising as quickly, according to Realtor.com senior economist Anthony Smith.
Several other Sun Belt metros saw home values plummet, including Phoenix, Denver, San Diego, and Los Angeles.
Meanwhile, metros in the Northeast and Midwest saw more promising numbers, with New York houses increasing the most in value, closely followed by Chicago.
‘Regionally, markets in the Northeast and Midwest continue to perform relatively better, supported by tighter resale supply and steadier demand,’ said Smith.
Southern metros with steep declines were Miami (pictured) and Dallas, both of which are also buyer’s markets.
Florida’s four major metro areas – Miami (pictured), Orlando, Tampa, and Jacksonville – are all buyer’s markets now
These regions saw residents flee to Sun Belt states during COVID in search of sun and space, but now their markets are more balanced than the pandemic boomtowns people ran to.
‘Markets that experienced the sharpest pandemic-era gains are now seeing the largest corrections, while more affordable metros with stable local economies are holding up better,’ says Godec.
‘Looking ahead, the housing market appears to be finding a new equilibrium after the pandemic boom.’
In August, home prices rose 1.5 percent over the year, below the 2.9 percent inflation rate, meaning home values are actually falling in real terms.
This is tough for current homeowners but may help buyers struggling with affordability, especially as mortgage rates recently dipped. Average rates fell to 6.19 percent last week, the lowest in over a year, as the Federal Reserve signals possible interest rate cuts.
‘With prices cooling and rates dropping, buying is becoming somewhat more affordable,’ BrightMLS Chief Economist Lisa Sturtevant told Realtor.com, ‘though economic uncertainty is keeping some people from buying.’