The Happiness Of Dogs by Mark Rowlands: Want to be happy? Be more DOG!
The Happiness Of Dogs Mark Rowlands (Granta £16.99, 256pp)
Humans, writes Mark Rowlands, ‘think we are smart because we think so much about everything all the time. Dogs think they are smart because they don’t think about everything all the time.’ He argues that the dogs are right. I agree with him.
As a professor of philosophy, Rowlands has been as keen to learn from Shadow as he has from Plato. Shadow is his German shepherd, who, every day, when the time comes to fetch Rowlands’ son from school, gets so excited that he grabs his own lead, throws it in the air so it lands on his back, then tries to insert his head through it.
Sometimes he succeeds. But even when he doesn’t, the moment still brings him joy.
How could we be as happy as Shadow? How could our lives be so fulfilled? ‘Human philosophers think about these questions,’ says Rowlands. ‘Dogs, on the other hand, live them. It is through their lives that they impart philosophical lessons, even though they have no idea what philosophy is.’ This book is an attempt to understand what those lessons are.
The central message is ‘stop thinking so much’. Many humans will look at Shadow’s unconfined delight at leaving the house and call him stupid. ‘But if that is what being stupid is,’ says Rowlands, ‘I wish someone would sign me up.’
He questions Socrates’s belief that ‘the unexamined life is not worth living’. Examining your life has massive costs: ‘Doubt is the child of reflection and dissatisfaction the child of doubt.’ Humans are ‘creatures of doubt. It riddles us, like a cancer.’
Because we have the ability to observe our own behaviour, we are ‘no longer fully immersed in life – we also, to an extent, stand apart from it’. We’re never fully committed to anything, not in the way a dog is: ‘Our commitment is always conditional,’ he writes.
Dogs evolved from wolves. They were the wolves that gradually got closer to humans and let those humans take care of them. As well as outsourcing their food and shelter requirements to the new owners, dogs even outsourced their thinking.
In experiments where they have to discover which cup is hiding some food, dogs always attempt to read a human’s face rather than work it out for themselves – it’s simply easier that way.
One happy dog: how could you become this happy?
They employ ‘left gaze bias’, focusing on the right side of the human face because it’s controlled by the left side of the brain, and so more accurately expresses underlying emotions.
Negative connotations come with the phrase ‘it’s a dog’s life’, but the simple canine existence has a lot in its favour.
Dogs can ‘take pleasure in the smallest things that life has to offer’: food, warmth, fetching a stick. The older I get, the more I agree. Not so much on the chasing sticks front, but you simply cannot beat the pleasure I get from sinking into my favourite sofa with a glass of my favourite beer. It may not seem much, but if it makes you happy, it’s everything.
Contentment is one thing, but philosophers also concern themselves with morality. Can a dog be said to be moral? Rowlands’ dogs would come and wake him in the night when his son was a baby and started crying, shoving their cold noses into his face to alert him to the fact that help was required.
He also gives the example of Lilica, a puppy abandoned at a junkyard in Sao Carlos, Brazil. She was taken in by the yard’s owner. A couple of miles down the road, Lilica discovered a woman who fed strays. Each night she would go there to be fed, but would also bring back a bag of food for the other animals who lived at the yard (dogs, cats, chickens and a mule).
Rowlands contends that this ‘certainly seems to be a strong candidate for moral behaviour’. In doing so he disagrees with legends of philosophy such as Aristotle and Kant, both of whom argued that animals can never be described as moral, because only humans can consider the motivations for their own behaviour.
I liked the author’s willingness to take on the poster boys of his subject, and indeed his dismissal of the field’s intellectual excesses. ‘Professional philosophers,’ he says, are ‘creatures who like to drain the magic out of life’s most vibrant phenomena.’ They ‘take delight in distinctions that would merely annoy anyone else’.
That’s not to say that parts of this book aren’t (to use Rowlands’ own phrase) ‘really, really hard’. But his overall argument is a winner. Our awareness of our own thoughts and actions makes us ‘spectators of [our lives] and, all too often, harping critics of them’.
You might think it ironic that a professor of philosophy is arguing against intelligence, but that shows his self-confidence. Humans cannot, of course, simply throw off their intelligence, like a coat they no longer want. But they can work towards becoming its master rather than its slave.
Think of great artists: ‘the virtuoso concert pianist lost in the Liszt sonata she is playing’. Or sport: ‘when we play, and all is going right, and we flow from one movement into the next, never thinking about ourselves and what we are doing, that is when we are most like our dogs’.
Clearly our advanced brains allow us to achieve fantastic things, and we’d be lost without them.
But in the end, ‘meaning in life exists wherever happiness erupts from nature. If you want to know the meaning of life, get a dog.’