1 of 3,911

The Eagle and The Hart by Helen Castor: How luxury loos flushed Richard II off his throne


The Eagle and the hart by Helen Castor (Allen Lane £35, 688pp)

The next time you blow your nose on your pocket hanky, remember to thank King Richard II of England (1367-1400) because he was the man who invented them.

This may sound like one of those rather trivial or dubious pub-quiz style factoids, but it’s well attested by contemporary chroniclers: ‘an accessory so new that there was not yet a word to describe it’. 

And, oddly, it does convey the very essence of Richard’s slightly fussy character, as unfolded in Castor’s dense, detailed and magisterial new 600-page door-stopper, telling the history of both the tragic Richard, and his very different successor, the ambitious and talented Henry IV.

There are tragic ironies right at the heart of the story of these two cousins. When Richard II was crowned king at the tender age of ten in Westminster Abbey, it was his cousin Henry who stood beside him holding the royal sword Curtana, ‘his face a mask of fierce concentration’.

Richard was fastidious, prissy. He married twice, but never produced any children. He was devoted to his great friend Robert de Vere, the Earl of Oxford, however, with whom he was said to have had an ‘obscene intimacy’ – at least by the gossipy Benedictine monk Thomas Walsingham. Who knows?

Castor seems much more astute in identifying one of Richard’s main characteristics as a chilly obsession with ‘distance and purity’ – those hankies again! – suggesting he may have been simply asexual in modern terms. But one thing is certain: de Vere’s close friendship and influence over Richard was resented by many other powerful nobles.

Henry IV – still Henry Bolingbroke at this time – was utterly different. Like Richard a grandson of Edward III, he was bluff, military, a loving husband and father of six children, including, crucially, four sons, and at least one illegitimate child to boot.

As time went on Richard became more tyrannical and mistrustful. He alienated London – never a good idea – imposing new taxes, and even moving part of the government apparatus, the Court of Common Pleas, north to York.

Worse still, gossip leaked out that Richard had spent still more money he didn’t have on luxurious bathrooms at his palace in Sheen, plumbed with hot and cold running water and bronze taps. 

Thone Fit for a King: Portrait of King Richard II and The First Lord Lumley

Thone Fit for a King: Portrait of King Richard II and The First Lord Lumley

This at a time when people were going genuinely hungry after a series of bad harvests. In a wonderful snippet from court records in 1391, a certain William Mildenhall of London was accused of failing to report his father for saying that the King was unfit to govern, and should jolly well stay in his lavatory for the rest of his days!

Henry, meanwhile, fought in the Northern Crusades and returned home a triumphant war hero.

Richard’s rather less impressive military campaigns included one rather pointless ‘punitive raid’ in Ireland, and an equally pointless invasion of Scotland. It was only the Scots falling out with their French allies – ‘the French found their hosts uncouth and uncultured’, and ‘their food inedible’ – that saved Richard from complete disaster.

Eventually, Richard was accused of having ridden roughshod over the laws of England, he was deposed and forced to sign a formal renunciation of his crown. He ended his days in Pontefract Castle and, according to contemporary accounts, as a dangerous focus of continuing revolt against Henry IV’s usurpation of the throne, was ‘miserably put to death by starvation’.

Henry IV was crowned in Westminster Abbey in October 1399, the Archbishop of Canterbury preaching from a text in the Book of Samuel: ‘A man shall rule over the people.’

The implication was clear to all: Henry IV was a real, strong, capable man, and Richard wasn’t. For several years after, Henry would have to fight and fight again to keep his throne against plots and rebellions from noblemen who had done less well out of his usurpation – but he knew how to fight, and he won. His son was Henry V, and his distant descendant today is King Charles III.



Read More

Leave a comment