‘Why can’t I find an affordable apartment?’ The Eagle’s housing reporter asks the
Why is it so difficult to find an apartment I can afford without skipping over items on my grocery list, canceling all my subscriptions or pulling from my savings?
A lot of us are asking ourselves, and our communities, this question.
I myself consider it daily — as a housing reporter, as a renter and as a member of Generation Z.
When I ask that question of my sources and the data, I often hear this: more people need somewhere to live than there are units available. And chances are, if a landlord can find someone who is willing to pay more, they’re going to raise the rent.
But the law of supply and demand can only take us so far. To answer this question, we also have to consider why there are so few units on the market.
I took that query to the president of Regan Development Corp., Larry Regan.
Regan Development is a family-owned real estate development company that builds affordable and “workforce” housing projects. They are currently finishing construction on 41 affordable apartments in the White Terrace building in Pittsfield.
In our conversation below, I asked Larry about the specific challenges faced by affordable housing developers who, unlike market rate developers, can’t increase rents to cover unforeseen construction costs.
We did not touch on the cost of land, zoning hiccups or maintenance costs in this interview, but keep in mind that those can also contribute to a developers’ expenses.
THE EAGLE: Take us from the beginning. A developer is interested in building an affordable apartment building — what’s the first expense they might encounter?
LARRY REGAN: Before you even encounter any expense, you have to make sure you have a deal that will get funded with the state’s funding mechanisms and you need to make sure the community is on board.
Affordable housing development on a per unit basis has gone up about 50 percent in costs, only in the last five to seven years because of cost escalations. These started to come out right before COVID happened and then when COVID happened the cost of development on the hard costs side skyrocketed and the cost of operations skyrocketed. Unless you have a proper pro forma, a proper budget, and you can work within the state funding guidelines and the local communities’ funding guidelines, you might as well not even start to look at building affordable housing. It’s very, very tricky.
THE EAGLE: How competitive is it to access that funding?
REGAN: It’s impossible. You spend a year getting your application ready with the knowledge that, in the state of Massachusetts, unless you have such star powers and your deal is so perfect or you have the politics to make sure you’re going to get completely funded on the first round, you’re not going to get funded on the first round. And there’s really only one round per year.
You need to go in thinking it’s going to be at least two years. So think about it, if you don’t own the property, you have to have site control for well over two plus, even three, years and think about how hard it is to keep a contract open for a seller who just wants his money for three years.
THE EAGLE: Say a developer does get the funding from the state and they’re ready to move forward, what are they facing then?
REGAN: You have to worry about cost escalation because you’re on the hook for that. You have to worry about interest rate increases because you have a construction loan that is underwritten for the application. …
You’re at the peril of all of the outside forces that could come about in the development process for additional costs.
THE EAGLE: You mentioned interest rate increases. Can you name the other outside forces that a developer might encounter that would raise costs?
REGAN: You’re subject to every cost escalation that could come about. Increases in lumber costs. Increases in costs of all of the copper that goes into the electrical equipment. Increases in any of the equipment — the PTAC, the HVAC units you put in.
Beyond cost escalations, increases in costs of insurance — not only the operation of insurance to get a liability policy or a a builder’s risk policy for the owners of the site (that’s gone up 40 percent over the past five years as well), but all of the insurance for every one of the subcontractors to the [general contractor] and the GC’s insurance have skyrocketed as well. So insurance costs are just added on to the costs that the GC and the subcontractors pass on to the developer, further burdening the financial load of the project.
All of the cost escalations, insurance, all of the costs of changes in regulations and the equipment — it’s all a nightmare. It’s a minefield that you really need to pay attention to.
THE EAGLE: What does all this mean for future renters of these affordable apartments?
REGAN: It doesn’t affect them because they’ll still pay the same rent, affordable rents. The tenant pays about 30 percent of their income, if they’re income qualified. And these tenants are typically pegged at up to 60 percent of the median income for the county that the affordable development is in.
That’s a little complicated, but the short answer to your question is that it’s not going to affect the tenants. What it’s going to affect is that the states do less development because the cost increases require the developers to ask for more subsidy and loan funding per deal, therefore cutting the amount of deals that the state can do because each developer needs to ask for 30 to 40 percent more in soft money and loans to make the sources meet uses.
They can’t increase their mortgage because they can’t increase their rents. If we were a market rate deal, we would simply add $200 to the cost of the unit and we would be able to have a higher permanent mortgage to bridge the gap of the cost increases. But because our incomes, and what we charge our tenants in rent, is fixed and capped by a formula that allows us only to charge 30 percent of the tenants 60 percent of the median income, then the state has no choice but to fill that gap to get deals done. And the 40 percent increase in costs over the past seven years has shrunken the amount of deals that Massachusetts, New York, New Jersey, Connecticut can do because they only get a finite amount of funding from the federal government and a finite amount of tax credits from the federal government and a finite amount of funding from the state.
THE EAGLE: And then that does, in a roundabout way, affect future tenants, no? There’s fewer affordable apartments that they can access in their area.
REGAN: Absolutely.
On a typical deal like we do in most states, we get thousands upon thousands of applications for a lottery for a finite number of units. Think about it, you get 7,000 applications for 100 units, there’s a real problem.


