Alive: an alternative anatomy by Gabriel Weston: Being in the room where life and death
Alive: an alternative anatomy by Gabriel Weston (Jonathan Cape £20, 304pp)
Alive, by the surgeon-writer Gabriel Weston, begins and ends with death. Over the first few pages, she gives an account of observing a pathologist open up the body of a woman to determine the cause of death. Weston vividly evokes the peeling and the slicing and the cracking. When I reached the point where the pathologist’s prising of the sternum up from the chest ‘makes a ripe plasticky noise, like cling film being ripped from a cardboard roll’, I had to take a moment.
Dr Gabriel Weston
And in a powerful final chapter, Weston, right, watches surgeons remove a young man’s organs to rush them to hospitals across the country. She struggles with the notion that ‘this time yesterday, the dead body on the table was a whole man with a whole life, and absolutely no idea that in one blind moment, and with one wrong move, he would pass through a catastrophic set of stages: from brother to pedestrian-versus-lorry, from friend to patient, from son to donor’.
Weston is an English graduate who switched to medicine. Her first book, Direct Red, a memoir about her life as a surgeon, was a critical success when published in 2009. Her idea for this title was ‘to look at anatomy with fresh eyes, approaching the subject more broadly than the humanities and medicine individually allow’.
Each chapter considers a particular organ and outlines its function and the history of our understanding of it, as well as featuring some insights of Weston’s own. It’s the latter that makes the book distinctive.
In the chapter on the liver she attends a ‘weekly Transplant List meeting’, at which medical staff decide which patients in need of a transplant are to be placed on the waiting list and which are to be removed from it – for example, someone who has become too frail to survive the operation is delisted.
‘Right now, in this conference room, life and death decisions are being made… patients must balance on a knife-edge between illness and fitness to be granted even a shot at salvation,’ Weston writes.
Some parts of the book were simply too graphic for me. I wish I hadn’t read this passage about skin ‘flaps’ and removing cancer from a face: ‘There’s usually a point when someone’s face is wide open and bleeding, and you don’t quite know how it’s all going to come together again.’
There’s a thread running throughout about Weston’s own heart problem and she also touches upon one of her children needing life-saving brain surgery. I’d have liked more on these. However, this is still a fascinating read – albeit one for a reader with a strong stomach.