Australian supermarket chocolate ice-cream taste test: ‘My scorecard read simply: “I’m
I grew up in a house barren of treats – there was no regular supply of chocolate, snakes, sour lollies or caramels. There was one exception: ice-cream, and I was mostly free to eat it whenever I wanted. That constant, childhood joy was the start of a storied love affair. Later, when I had money to buy my lunch in high school, I would get a one-litre tub, a pair of spoons, and my friend and I would eat the entire thing and nothing else. Sometimes, if we were particularly greedy, we’d split a two-litre tub.
I thought tasting more than 20 varieties of supermarket chocolate ice-creams would be like a reunion tour of my favourite teenage-era bands, an hours-long journey of nostalgia, glee and excess. But my dream shattered in a supermarket ice-cream aisle when my dad, who was with me to help collect products for the taste test, asked: “Is this ice-cream?” The tub was in the ice-cream section, and the packaging showed pictures of chocolate ice-cream scoops. But nowhere did it say the words “ice-cream” or “gelato”.
Turns out this wasn’t going to be a tasting of 23 chocolate ice-creams, it would be a tasting of 14 chocolate ice-creams and nine almost ice-creams, mostly “frozen desserts”, products so frugal in their use of dairy, they’re legally barred from the honour of calling themselves ice-cream. Even of the official ice-creams, four of the products are so aerated they’re more like eating mildly flavoured mousse. (For this reason, price per litre only tells you so much about the value of a product. Check the weight on the nutrition panel – if an ice-cream is one litre but weighs 500g, what you’re paying for is a lot of air. If it weighs 900g, you’re paying for a lot of cream.) If this taste test is a reunion tour, it’s a cover band and half the band members are hungover.
Nine other ice-cream enthusiasts joined me for the taste test. We tasted the products blind, scoring for texture, taste and chocolatey-ness, but only texture and taste counted in the product’s final score (you can have a delicious ice-cream that’s not particularly chocolatey and vice versa). What we found was a solid mid-range of ice-creams with few weird and wonderful standouts, and nine frozen desserts that varied from just passable as ice-cream to sugar-flavour freezer ice. For that reason frozen desserts and the most aerated ice-creams have been excluded from the write-up below, but you can find their scores in the table below.
A note on dietary products:
There are no standouts. I think Elato, a coconut-based gelato with a mild and unusual sweetness, is the better option for vegan and lactose-free eaters. De Nada is a decent low-sugar option – it’s pretty chocolatey, but I can taste the artificial sweetener alongside an odd stale flavour. I can find no conceivable reason to buy a protein-added ice-cream – they are neither particularly healthy, high in protein or economical. I also question why they exist. Looking for health improvements in the ice-cream section is like inviting a health and safety officer to a duel – did we forget why we’re here? If you need the protein, sprinkle some nuts on top.