1 of 3,920

The Cottonwoods: Steamboat’s first for-sale affordable housing project in decades


The Cottonwoods at Mid Valley, spearheaded by the Yampa Valley Housing Authority, is set to become a transformative development for Routt County’s housing landscape, offering 86 deed-restricted condos for sale to local workers, retirees and families — marking the first major for-sale affordable housing project in Steamboat Springs in around two decades. 

YVHA Executive Director Jason Peasley, Communications and Community Engagement Coordinator John Fancher, and Sales and Asset Manager Alyssa Cartmill sat down with the newspaper on Nov. 19 to discuss updates surrounding The Cottonwoods and to underscore growing excitement from prospective buyers.

The project provides a rare opportunity for the valley’s workforce to purchase homes at prices significantly below market, with units ranging from the mid-$200,000s to the mid-$400,000s. Fancher said the pricing amounts to “a discount to market (rate) of up to 56%.”



“Those are unheard of prices right now,” said Peasley. “I think people’s next question is, ‘OK, how do I get my hands on that?’ or ‘What would it take for me to live there?’”

These units are discounted thanks to $10 million in short-term rental tax revenue allocated to The Cottonwoods by the Steamboat Springs City Council. Otherwise, Cottonwoods prices would have been in the mid-$400,000s to mid-$700,000s, Fancher said.



The development is tailored for households earning up to 140% of the Area Median Income, explained Cartmill, with two down-payment assistance programs — one for up to 150% of AMI and another for up to 120% of AMI — each offering up to $20,000 in “silent” second loans that are only repaid after 15 years, or if the home is refinanced or sold.

These programs, funded by city, state and Proposition 123 dollars, are not limited to The Cottonwoods but can be used countywide.​

In addition to the 140% AMI cap, at least one member of the applicant’s household must either work in Routt County or be retired from employment in Routt County. 

Applicants are also required to sign an affidavit stating that they intend to reside in the unit full-time. All members of the household are forbidden from owning another home, condominium or mobile home in Colorado; if they do, they must sell within 180 days.

Construction remains on track for completion in early 2026, said Peasley, with the first building expected to come online about a month ahead of the second. 

As of Nov. 19, approximately 320 community members have completed the pre-screening form, with about 280 found eligible for the deed restriction, according to Cartmill.

Peasley noted that the $10 million in STR funding has allowed YVHA to reach back out to some previously ineligible applicants, hoping to convert more into eligible buyers as pricing has shifted downward. 

“I think it opens the market for the housing authority,” said Cartmill. “Most of what we’ve done recently has been on that rental and lower-income side, so I think this is a huge opportunity just to re-engage the community … to say, ‘Hey, we’re here to support you also, and we have a product for you.’”​

The most common occupations among those who have submitted the pre-screening form, said Fancher, are within the government, hospitality, education and healthcare industries.

Once initially deemed eligible, applicants will move to a full application, including income verification and proof of employment before entering a randomized lottery for unit selection.​

“If you’re the one who’s selected for that (unit), you are not going to have some all-cash buyer come in and swoop that unit out from under you,” said Peasley. “You have the right, once you win the lottery, to go under contract immediately for that unit.”

“This eliminates some of the headaches that I think a lot of local home buyers have experienced over the course of probably the last five years, which is, ‘OK, I’m ready, I found the place that I want, and there were six all-cash offers that out-competed me,’” he continued. “That’s a story we’ve heard time and time again.” 

Fancher explained that YVHA is facilitating the lottery process using a third-party software through Salesforce, “reducing any element of human error.” 

“Then the buyer can select one or as many units that they’re interested in,” he said. “And if you’re really lucky, you may have to make a decision” between multiple units.  

The deed restriction, which will remain in place for subsequent buyers as well as the initial buyer, also limits resale appreciation to either a 2% annual return or half of the annual AMI growth, preserving affordability for future buyers while allowing owners to build some equity.​

This means the owner’s return could be as low as 2% in a slow year, but could rise to 5% (or more, depending on the AMI growth rate) in a strong year. 

“If you purchased a unit in Year 1 for $400,000, by the end of five years — based on real AMI growth — you would have had an equity appreciation of $126,000,” said Fancher.

“We’re trying to keep as much of that money in the buyer and seller’s pocket, not just on the initial sale, but in the continuance for resales and some of those other pieces,” said Cartmill. “So you’re not trying to argue commissions or have someone trying to take that away.”

YVHA staff, including Cartmill and Housing Navigator Araceli Googins, are providing support beyond financial assistance, guiding applicants through the homebuying process and connecting them with local lenders and free financial literacy classes. 

“I think that’s the most uncomfortable part, right? Most people don’t want to talk about their financial situation because everyone’s is so different,” said Cartmill. “Araceli (Googins) has really thrived in that area.” 

The pre-screening form remains open, serving as the entry point for prospective buyers to determine their eligibility and begin the journey toward homeownership at The Cottonwoods. 

Cartmill reflected on the excitement in the community among prospective buyers.

“This is the opportunity for the workforce to buy something that’s new, to have that shiny new item,” she said. “They’ve said, ‘I’ve been holding off for 10 years and I’m finally getting a chance to stay in Steamboat, the town that I’ve worked in for the last 20 years. I’ve worked three jobs and I’ve been doing all this to save and waiting for this moment, and it’s here,’ and that’s really heartwarming.”

“I see Araceli get teary-eyed with someone probably once a week from their story and how excited they are … and the opportunities to move from rental to this, and now they can expand their family,” Cartmill added. “You can see the buildings. They have siding on them now. It’s becoming a very real and tangible thing.”

To learn more about The Cottonwoods at Mid Valley or to fill out the pre-screening form, visit YVHA.org/Cottonwoods/.

Drone shot of The Cottonwoods at Mid Valley, set to complete construction in early 2026.
Courtesy photo/Yampa Valley Housing Authority


Read More
Leave a comment