After Trying 13 Different Marinara Sauces, This Is The 1 We'll Be Buying Again
Marinara sauce is the fresh and tangy base to a variety of Italian dishes. From a tomatoey pasta dish or a flavorful pizza topping to a tangy dipping sauce for appetizers or breadsticks, marinara is a staple for bringing bright flavor to the foods we love.
When it comes to choosing the perfect marinara sauce, it can be a tough decision to make. Whether you’re layering it into lasagna or serving a spoonful over a slice of crusty bread, the type of marinara sauce you choose matters. Thankfully, our editors tasted 13 different store-bought marinara sauces to help you make a more educated purchase next time you head to the store.
How We Tested
We poured each jar of marinara sauce into separate bowls, microwaved them, and hid the packaging, so each tester could sample the sauces without seeing which brand they were tasting.
Editors sampled the sauces side by side, scoring them on taste, texture, and overall experience using a scale from 1 to 5, with 1 being the lowest and 5 being the highest. After everyone ranked their picks, we tallied the results to find the winner.
The Contenders
- Ragu Kettle Cooked Marinara
- Simply Nature
- 365 Organic Marinara
- TJ’s Organic Marinara Sauce
- Bertolli
- Carbone
- Prego
- Great Value Marinara
- Rao’s
- Good & Gather
- Publix Marinara Sauce
- Michaels of Brooklyn
- Victoria White Linen Marinara
How Each Brand Scored
Ragu Kettle Cooked Marinara
Many of us grew up eating Ragu Old-World Style marinara sauce, but their Kettle-Cooked Marinara is slowly simmered, giving it a richer, more homemade taste. One editor said Ragu had “a nice and mild, good garlic flavor. Not too chunky, with a pretty red color.” Another editor said, “just makes me want a big bowl of pasta!” Our editors liked the fresh and bright tomato flavor of Ragu as well as its richness and mild acidity, but a few noted the herbs tasted a bit stale, not as fresh as we’d like.
Simply Nature
Simply Nature is Aldi’s brand of organic marinara sauce. Many editors noted the chunkier, almost salsa-like texture of this sauce and said that its basic flavor would be great for building off of in a recipe. Try it as the base of your sauce for spaghetti and meatballs or a hearty dish of lasagna.
365 Organic Marinara
Whole Foods’ 365 Organic Marinara is chock full of herbs like basil and oregano. One editor said you can see the basil and oregano in the sauce, and the flavor certainly comes through, so you wouldn’t need to add much seasoning to this sauce before enjoying.
Trader Joe’s Organic Marinara Sauce
Our editors noted that Trader Joe’s Organic Marinara Sauce is definitely on the thicker side with chunks of tomato dispersed throughout. For those that prefer a more textured, chunky sauce, this one may be for you. Try it on pizza, chicken Parmesan, or a slice of crusty bread.
Bertolli
“This one is flavorful. I like that it’s slightly chunky and has some basil to it,” wrote one editor. While our editors felt this sauce had slightly more texture to it, it was not as chunky as some others in the taste test. Overall, Bertolli has a slightly sweet, slightly herb-forward flavor with a medium texture.
Carbone
“Tastes the most homemade,” said one editor about Carbone marinara sauce. “Not too sweet, very bright and fresh, good texture, not too chunky.” Our editors liked that Carbone’s sauce was a nice balance of herbs and tomatoes without being too overpowering. Many felt like the balanced flavor and texture of Carbone would make it great to eat on its own.
Prego
Another sauce many of us grew up enjoying, Prego is a classic and affordable marinara sauce. While some of the sauces in our taste test run closer to $7 or $8 a jar, Prego is quite affordable at $2.48. Our editors said Prego is a good, basic sauce that you could eat as is or add to it. For a middle-of-the-road option that doesn’t break the bank, this is a great choice.
Great Value Marinara
Walmart’s Great Value Marinara “is a nice middle-of-the-road sauce,” said an editor, “that is fairly smooth with bits of onion.” One editor expressed that because of its thinner consistency, Great Value marinara would be a good building sauce.
Rao’s
“This one feels perfect for spaghetti and meatballs,” wrote an editor about Rao’s marinara sauce. With a nice balance of richness and texture, the salty and sweet sauce with a prominent garlic flavor would be great on cheesy pasta like ravioli or tortellini.
Good & Gather
“This one tastes very classic,” said an editor about Target’s Good & Gather marinara. “There’s something nostalgic to it.” With a more subtle flavor, this marinara could be a great multipurpose sauce for soups, stews, pasta, or chicken and fish dishes.
Publix Marinara Sauce
Publix Marinara Sauce has a strong tomato-forward flavor with a consistency that our editors said would, “coat noodles nicely” and “hold onto spaghetti well.” With plenty of herbs, and a touch of sweetness, Publix marinara is a sauce our editors wouldn’t mind serving with a comforting bowl of pasta.
Michaels of Brooklyn
A beloved Italian sauce from the classic Brooklyn restaurant, Michaels of Brooklyn marinara sauce is one our editors thought tasted homemade and not as processed as other sauces. One editor wrote that they, “love the tomato chunks and the richness,” of Michaels marinara. With a good flavor and strong notes of basil, our editors thought this sauce would serve well over tortellini or ravioli.
Victoria White Linen Marinara
“Rich almost zesty, and nicely balanced,” wrote an editor about Victoria White Linen Marinara, which we purchased at Costco. With a strong tomato flavor and good bit of seasoning, this sauce would be perfect on pizza or a great base to build off of.
The Runner-Up
Morgan Hunt Ward; Prop Stylist: Abby Armstrong; Food Stylist: Emily Nabors Hall
The runner-up of our taste test is Victoria White Linen Marinara Sauce. “This has all the right stuff going on,” wrote an editor. With a “meaty, slow-cooked tomato flavor,” our editors liked the strong flavor you get from this sauce without any aftertaste or bits that stick to your tongue.
The Winner
Morgan Hunt Ward; Prop Stylist: Abby Armstrong; Food Stylist: Emily Nabors Hall
Carbone is the winner of our marinara taste test and the sauce our editors said tasted the most homemade. Our editors love Carbone for it’s balanced taste and texture. Here are just a few of their comments:
“Tastes the most like homemade. Not too sweet, very bright and fresh, good texture, not too chunky.”
“The best balance of herbs and tomatoes for a basic sauce that’s ready to go.”
“Carbone is the best for the most perfect, straight-out-of-the-jar flavor.”
“Has a good depth of flavor and a smooth consistency which I like. It has a nice acidity and no overpowering herbs.”