1 of 3,903

UPDATE: Realtors push back after study ranks Chattanooga among most overpriced housing


UPDATE: A recent study ranked Chattanooga 40th among the 50 U.S. cities with the most overpriced homes, but several local real estate professionals say the report does not fully reflect the realities of the area’s housing market.

The study, conducted by MoneyLion, compared average home values with median listing prices and found nearly an 18% gap in Chattanooga. While the ranking generated attention, some local realtors said the methodology raises questions and lacks important context.

“It shocked me,” Realtor Adam Reeves said. “I’ll be honest, to see that we were right there, even just in the top 50.”

Realtor Whitney Proctor said one of her primary concerns is the study’s use of average home values and median listing prices as comparison points.

“Anybody who knows anything about math — or better yet, if you know nothing about math — you know that there’s a big difference between the average and the median number,” Proctor said. “So immediate red flags right there.”

Proctor recently posted a video breaking down local Multiple Listing Service (MLS) data, arguing that median sales figures provide a more accurate picture of market conditions.

According to data she cited from the Chattanooga MLS, the median original listing price was $360,000, the median final listing price was $350,000 and the median sold price was $345,000.

“That’s not even 5%,” Proctor said. “What that’s saying is that from the original list price to the closed price, you had about a 5% negotiation or price drop.”

Other local real estate professionals echoed the need to closely examine how housing studies are conducted.

“Always consider the source and understand the parameters of whatever the source is citing,” said Becky Cope English, partner and managing broker at The Agency Chattanooga. “Is it the MSA? Is it just Chattanooga? Is it Tennessee or Georgia?”

English said real estate trends can vary significantly depending on the geographic area being analyzed and that broad market reports may overlook neighborhood-level differences.

Connie Brewer, president of Greater Chattanooga Realtors, also questioned the usefulness of measuring “home value” across a large geographic area.

“Real estate is specialized and hyperlocal, which is why the expertise and research of a realtor are so important for homebuyers and sellers,” Brewer said in a statement.

Brewer noted that factors such as a home’s age, condition, location and need for repairs can significantly impact its value. She said the median sales price is often a more meaningful metric because it reflects what buyers are actually willing to pay.

According to Greater Chattanooga Realtors data, the Chattanooga Metropolitan Statistical Area — which includes Catoosa, Dade, Hamilton, Marion, Sequatchie and Walker counties — posted a median sales price of $355,000 from January through April 2026, up $10,000 from the same period in 2025.

Meanwhile, Hamilton County recorded a median sales price of $380,000 during the same period, down $5,000 from the previous year.

Local realtors also point to increasing inventory as a positive sign for buyers.

“The same time last year, we had 3,336 homes on the market,” Realtor Jules Parker said. “One year later, we have over 4,000. I think we are at 4,057 homes on the market, and that really helps.”

More inventory generally gives buyers additional options and can create opportunities for negotiation, realtors said.

“We’ve been able to negotiate the price of the home, we’ve been able to negotiate some repairs from the seller, we’ve been able to negotiate some closing costs, whatever that needs to look like,” Reeves said.

Despite differing opinions on the MoneyLion study, Chattanooga-area real estate professionals agreed that buyers and sellers should seek guidance from experts familiar with the local market.

“You need to be educated, you need to be prepared, and the best place you’re going to get that is with a local realtor who knows the neighborhood,” English said.

Parker added that working closely with a realtor can help buyers identify homes that fit their budgets and goals.

Brewer said the region continues to attract new residents and remains a desirable place to live, but emphasized that understanding local market conditions requires more than reviewing national rankings.

“At the end of the day, real estate is more than numbers on a screen,” Brewer said. “Every home, every neighborhood and every community tells a different story.”


PREVIOUS STORY: A recent study by MoneyLion puts Chattanooga at 40th on the list of “50 Places With the Most Overpriced Homes.”

Of those 50 cities, 45 are in southern states.

The study, released on May 19, shows Chattanooga’s average home value in 2026 sits at $321,191.

The median list price for a home in Chattanooga is $378,211. That makes the difference between the median list price and the home value $57,020, which is 17.8% higher.

Knoxville sits even higher on that list at #34, with an average home value of $362,760 and a median list price of $433,340. That’s a 19.5% difference.

In comparison, the average home value in the United States is $367,000, and the median list price is about $400,000. The average difference in value versus list price in the U.S. is 9%.

Notably, the median wage in Chattanooga is $24-$25 per hour. The average wage rose 4% from May 2024 to May 2025, but it’s still lower than the national average. Many Chattanooga residents have said it’s not enough to make ends meet.

Additionally, most of the people relocating to Chattanooga from out-of-state are from California, a study by the University of Tennessee at Chattanooga revealed. Newcomers cite affordability, quality of life and economic opportunity.

The #1 most expensive city to buy a home in the U.S. is Santa Maria, California. The MoneyLion study says that homes are overpriced by more than $300,000 in two California cities.





Read More

Leave a comment