Is your loved one unable to tell you what’s wrong with them? This is the vital question
A patient in distress is normally able to explain what’s wrong or point to their symptoms, but what happens when somebody cannot easily communicate what’s going on – or doctors don’t know how to listen properly?
Last Wednesday marked ten years since Oliver McGowan died, aged just 18. Oliver had autism, a learning disability and epilepsy – and had been admitted to hospital after suffering seizures.
He and his parents repeatedly warned doctors that he had reacted badly to antipsychotic medication in the past, yet he was still given one. He suffered a severe adverse reaction, which contributed to his death.
His parents have spent the years since campaigning to make sure other families do not go through what they did – and thanks to their efforts, NHS staff must now undergo additional training in learning disabilities and autism. An extraordinary legacy.
Central to his story – and so many others involving needless harms and deaths – is medical staff not adequately listening to patients or their families.
That matters especially for those who have difficulty communicating their symptoms, including people with learning disabilities, autism or dementia – potentially millions of people in the UK.
For those who have difficulty communicating their symptoms, including people with learning disabilities, autism or dementia, pain or discomfort can manifest as agitation or aggression
Dementia is one of the clearest examples of why this matters. Patients may not be able to tell us that they have toothache, constipation, a urine infection or simply that something hurts. Instead, they may become agitated or aggressive, stop eating, withdraw or suddenly become much more confused.
The danger is that we see that change and think, ‘their dementia is getting worse’, when actually they may simply be trying to tell us – in the only way they are able to – that something physical is wrong.
Pain is a good example. A new study in the Journal of Clinical Nursing, which looked at the medical notes of 50 dementia patients, found that only five received pain relief within an hour of admission to hospital – despite many having arrived with fractures or serious infections.
The problem for someone with dementia is they cannot say, ‘my hip hurts’ or ‘I have terrible abdominal pain’ – the distress may come out as agitation or aggression instead, which we then put down to the dementia.
And this matters because people with dementia have little margin for us getting it wrong.
A study recently published in the journal PLoS One by researchers at my own medical school, Brighton and Sussex, followed more than 30,000 older people with dementia after an emergency hospital admission and found that four in ten were back in hospital within six months.
That does not prove their original care was poor, but suggests how missing something treatable such as pain, infection or constipation can potentially matter.
This is why relatives play a vital role. The dementia patient’s husband, wife, son or daughter will often know immediately that their behaviour is different from normal – and telling doctors may be the thing that makes us stop and ask whether we are missing a physical cause.
It is a similar situation for people with disabilities. A study, published in PLoS Medicine in August, found that almost 40 per cent of deaths among adults with severe or profound learning disabilities were classified as potentially avoidable – far higher than in the general population.
As with the dementia patient, if a child with a learning disability becomes agitated we may well assume their behaviour is part of their disability.
So why can doctors sometimes be worse at recognising illness in these vulnerable groups?
Medics like to imagine that we are logical. We collect the information, weigh it up and calmly reach the correct conclusion.
But much of the time we cannot painstakingly work through every possible diagnosis from scratch every time we see a patient; experience allows us to recognise patterns quickly.
There have been times when my daughter Frankie has been incredibly upset and her behaviour has changed, and I have put that down to her underlying condition, writes Dr Rob Galloway
The problem is that the first answer that jumps into our head can feel so obviously right that we do not even realise we have made an assumption.
I know how easy this is because I have fallen into the same trap myself when looking after my most precious patient – my two-and-a-half-year-old daughter Frankie.
She has a very rare genetic condition, DeSanto-Shinawi syndrome, which causes a learning disability and communication difficulties. She cannot always tell us what is hurting or why she is distressed.
There have been times when Frankie has been incredibly upset and her behaviour has changed, and I have put that down to her underlying condition rather than stopping to ask whether something else was going on.
Only later have we realised that our daughter was actually in significant pain because she was constipated – a problem related to her condition.
As a doctor – and someone who teaches and has even co-written a textbook on medical cognitive bias – I still missed it.
That’s because I had an explanation in my head for why her behaviour was so difficult – and I stopped looking hard enough for another one.
Doctors need to recognise when to slow down, switch to more deliberate thinking – and ask ourselves, ‘what else could this be?’
This is why relatives need to tell their doctor what’s changed – a parent may know that their child’s cry sounds different. A husband may know that his wife with dementia is normally confused, but has never refused food before.
Perhaps the most useful thing you can say is: ‘This is different from their normal.’
And ask: ‘Could there be another explanation?’
In Frankie’s case, that simple question would have been: ‘Could this change in behaviour actually be because she is in pain rather than simply being what we expected from her underlying condition as she ages?’
If you remain worried or unsure, ask for a more senior doctor to review your relative.
And if they are deteriorating in hospital and you still feel your concerns are not being heard, ask about Martha’s Rule. Where it is available, patients and families can request a rapid review from a different team.
The important message is: tell us when this is not normal for the person you know and love.
Because the best care does not come from doctors (and patients and relatives) assuming the clinician is right, but from patients, families and healthcare professionals working together to find the right answer.