1 of 3,876

Tribunal dismisses Almacantar’s BSA appeal to recover Centre Point leaseholder costs


The First-tier Tribunal has dismissed an appeal by Almacantar to recover service charges from leaseholders to pay for building safety repairs at its Centre Point House scheme in central London.

The case arose from construction faults at Centre Point House, near the junction of Charing Cross Road and New Oxford Street, which resulted in water ingress, degradation and rot of the timber frames, with the total repair cost expected to exceed £12m.

The appeal, launched last month, questioned whether the Building Safety Act (BSA) protected qualifying leaseholders against remediation costs only if there was a statutory ‘relevant defect’.

Almacantar’s appeal questioned a paragraph of schedule 8 in the BSA on cladding remediation, defined as the removal or replacement of any part of a cladding system that is part of an external wall system and is unsafe. But the tribunal dismissed Almacantar’s appeal, arguing that the word ‘unsafe’ was not restricted to fire risks.

Julia Tobbell, partner, real estate disputes, at Forsters, which acted on behalf of one of the leaseholders, said the ruling had “significant consequences for not only the implementation of the groundbreaking BSA 2022, but for the lives of many leaseholders across the country, too”.

She added: “Although the cladding design at Centre Point House is unique, this judgment will have implications for other types of unusual cladding, or cladding which is found to be unsafe for any reason other than fire risk.

“This judgment is another example of the purposive approach being given by the courts and tribunals to the act. The reason for the intervention, and the numerous comments made by government when promoting the bill, make clear that improving safety standards, and financial protection for ordinary people living in their homes, was paramount.”

Later this week, the Supreme Court is set to hear further cases about the costs of fixing safety defects in residential buildings under the BSA. It will examine the case of Adriatic Land v long leaseholders at Hippersley Point, a building in south London, and the case of Stratford Village v Triathlon Homes, involving remediation costs relating to the Get Living’s east London scheme.

Earlier this month, Urban Splash was ordered to pay over £45m to the government to cover the cost of fixing historic fire safety issues at seven high-rise buildings in Manchester.

Almacantar declined to comment.



Read More

Leave a comment