Return-to-office has settled. Is this as good as it gets for downtown? – The Boston Globe
“We thought Amazon was the first domino,” Baratz said. “But then, not really. . . . We would love to have more business. Honestly, it’s at the point where Fridays are boring.”
Ever since offices reopened in the pandemic, businesspeople have wondered when the “new normal” would arrive. Office employers typically started with one or two days a week in the office. Many of the companies, from John Hancock to CarGurus, have now settled in at three. For a few, such as State Street, four became the rule.
As of Labor Day, nearly every company seems to be sticking with its current hybrid approach, based on interviews with more than two dozen local business leaders. Yes, the office leasing market has finally stabilized, and city leaders are trying to encourage housing construction. But for the businesses that depend on downtown office workers, this could be as good as it gets.
Consider the MBTA’s commuter rail numbers. Initially, Boston had one of the strongest commuter rail recoveries of any major city. But the momentum has slowed. Ridership dropped by 7 percent in the first six months of 2025, compared with 2024; it was down 16 percent from 2019 levels. (A T spokesperson said slow zones that affected nearby subway lines skewed the commuter rail numbers upward last year.)
Surveys by the Greater Boston Chamber of Commerce and Massachusetts Business Roundtable show most employers have settled into hybrid schedules — with no further changes expected.
“It feels like they’ve figured it out,” Roundtable president JD Chesloff said. “They’re settling in on their policy, which is predominantly hybrid.”
It’s a different story in Manhattan, where office visits in July surpassed prepandemic levels for the first time, according to foot traffic data analyzed by Placer.ai. New York was the first to reach that milestone. Miami is close behind. In Boston, however, office visits remained down 30 percent from July 2019.
“It has pretty much leveled off here in Boston,” said Tucker White, US office agency lead for market intelligence at real estate brokerage Avison Young.
Still, the Downtown Business Alliance remains optimistic.
Foot traffic downtown rose 8 percent in the first six months of 2025 compared to the same time in 2024, according to data from the landlord-backed group, though it was still around three-quarters of 2019 levels. President Michael Nichols points to the successful lease-up of the new Winthrop Center tower, marketing tech firm Klaviyo’s decision to add nearly 100,000 square feet at 125 Summer St., and a third straight quarter of increases in occupied office space.
Oxford Properties vice president Matt Polhemus said Oxford’s offices at 125 Summer St. are around 90 percent leased, its 225 Franklin St. building is close behind, and ground-floor restaurants Cava and Tatte are seeing their best-ever revenue.
At Synergy, another major downtown landlord, tours by potential occupants have picked up, executive Jim Grady said. That’s one reason he expects in-office days will continue to grow, particularly in finance and law.
Bryan Montgomery, researcher with brokerage JLL, said he expects nearly all the major post-COVID office downsizings have already taken place. One positive sign he cited: No sublease has hit the downtown market in almost a year for more than 50,000 square feet.
Still, around one in four downtown office spaces remains empty, or close to 10 million square feet, the equivalent of five John Hancock towers. With few big employers looking to move, expand downtown, or ramp up return-to-office requirements, it’s hard to see that improving significantly anytime soon.
Downtown boosters aren’t waiting for pre-COVID commuting patterns to return.
The Downtown Business Alliance is trying to make the area less reliant on office workers by promoting events, tourist attractions, and nightlife options. Some creative conversions have emerged amid the decline in property values: One office building, for example, was torn down to make way for a new Holocaust museum.
The big hope for downtown? More housing. Boston’s central business district has far fewer apartments than similar downtowns in other US cities. Mayor Michelle Wu’s administration is trying two approaches to change this: a tax break for office-to-residential conversions, and a rezoning proposal to allow taller buildings.
At a business event in June, Wu pointed to the roughly 800 units in the conversion pipeline. But construction has been slow. While work has started on a few conversions elsewhere in the city, only one such project in the tax-break program has started in the core downtown — the newly completed 15 apartments in a Franklin Street building that Wu highlighted in an event on Tuesday.

Then there’s the thornier issue of allowing taller towers, particularly among the blocks closest to Boston Common. The Wu administration drafted a new rezoning plan to accomplish this, but has delayed its approval amid pushback from neighbors. Still, Wu signaled at a recent event she remains committed to it, noting the best place in Boston for taller residential towers is “in the downtown core.”
And Wu presided over a meeting on Friday with developers, business leaders, and residents to discuss further tweaks to the downtown zoning, with a goal of spurring more housing. The latest revisions include strict height limits along Washington Street for buildings that are not primarily residential, and a requirement that any proposal for a structure with more than 250,000 square feet of offices obtain additional zoning approval.
Among those waiting for the rezoning is Midwood Investment chief executive John Usdan, owner of a forlorn block at the corner of Washington and Bromfield streets.
Usdan has been trying to build a tower there for two decades. He started with a residential concept, switched to offices, and has now returned to apartments. He said foot traffic has returned to pre-COVID levels in Philadelphia’s Center City, where Midwood also operates, in large part because of a rezoning years ago to allow for more residential density. Something similar could revive Downtown Crossing, he said.
Rishi Shukla, of the Downtown Boston Neighborhood Association, said creating a vibrant, mixed-use downtown depends on ensuring that people feel safe when walking around. He has seen major improvements since a February safety summit. Making it easier to get business permits would also help. But a “hodgepodge of towers” isn’t going to do the job, he said, especially if it threatens the area’s historic character and casts long shadows on its open spaces.

Many of these projects will take years. In the meantime, downtown needs more foot traffic. And office employers may still have a role to play. For example, as the federal government brings people back on a full-time basis, city and state officials are facing calls to do the same.
Among private employers, some stragglers are catching up with the norm. Cybersecurity firm Snyk is requiring employees who live nearby to come in three days a week, starting in January. Chief executive Peter McKay said in-person work encourages collaboration and builds a corporate culture.
“Could we have done it a year ago?” McKay said. “We felt we would have lost some really good people if we rushed it too much.”
That is the main reason most employers are sticking with their current plans — whether it’s simply allowing workers to stay home on Fridays, or moving ahead without any requirement at all.
Mindy Lubber, chief executive of sustainability nonprofit Ceres, doesn’t want to alienate the dozens of remote workers she hired during the pandemic so she has not implemented a mandatory return-to-office policy.
Offering free bagels or pizza has helped, but only slightly. Instead of 15 people, the free food days might draw 25.
“I’m so convinced you work better, you learn better . . . if you’re in an office across from each other,” Lubber said. “[But] it was a different world, and we have not been successful in pulling people back to the old way.”
Jon Chesto can be reached at jon.chesto@globe.com. Follow him @jonchesto.