I just moved from New York to Australia and it’s like walking into a parallel universe –
An American woman who moved from New York to Melbourne has revealed she was stunned by how similar the two cities were, describing Australia as a ‘parallel universe’ where everything feels familiar yet slightly different.
Kayleigh, 27, expected a major culture shock when she relocated Down Under, but quickly discovered that Melbourne’s bustling streets, cafe culture and cosmopolitan atmosphere reminded her of home.
It was only when she noticed cars travelling on the opposite side of the road or unfamiliar shopfronts that she remembered she was living on the other side of the world.
With young Australians drawn to the US by career opportunities and big-city living, Americans are making the journey in reverse, attracted by the beaches, outdoor lifestyle and opportunities to travel while working.
Kayleigh was among those seeking a change of scenery, leaving New York last year on a working holiday visa.
‘I just moved to Australia from New York and I’m going through some of the biggest culture shocks that I’ve noticed so far,’ she said in a video filmed two months after arriving.
‘The first is that things are not that different here and it honestly feels like a parallel universe.
‘I live in Melbourne now and it feels so much like New York City until you look up and see a different store name, or until you see cars on the other side of the road.’
An American woman who moved from New York to Melbourne has revealed she was stunned by how similar the two cities were
‘Everything feels the same, but flipped.’
Speaking to the Daily Mail, the hospitality worker revealed she has now spent more than a year in Australia, living in Melbourne, on an island near Cairns, and on the Gold Coast.
‘I moved from New York to try and experience somewhere new,’ she said.
But despite the similarities between the two cities, Kayleigh soon discovered that Australians approached certain everyday activities very differently.
One of her biggest surprises was the level of trust people appeared to place in complete strangers.
‘So many things are an honour system here, like getting gas,’ she said.
Unlike in much of the US, where drivers pay before filling up, Australian motorists can generally pump their petrol before heading inside to settle the bill.
She was equally surprised by her experiences at the cinema and on Melbourne’s tram network.
Kayleigh, 27, expected a major culture shock when she relocated Down Under, but quickly discovered that Melbourne’s atmosphere reminded her of home
‘I went to the movies the other day, they don’t even check your ticket. They just trust that you’re going to do the right thing,’ she said.
‘The trams here – they trust that you’re going to pay for them.’
Although Melbourne passengers must pay their fares and can be checked by authorised officers, Kayleigh was struck by the absence of ticket barriers.
She found it amusing that the same trust didn’t always extend to retail stores, where staff sometimes inspected shoppers’ bags.
Perhaps even more surprising was the sight of dogs tied up outside supermarkets while their owners went shopping.
‘People also leave their dogs everywhere. You would never trust that in America,’ she said.
While Melbourne’s cafe culture felt familiar, Kayleigh discovered that getting a coffee in the afternoon was considerably harder than in New York.
‘The coffee is so good but everything closes by 3pm, sometimes 2pm. So if you don’t go and get it before that, you’re just going to be getting your coffee at McDonald’s later in the day,’ she said.
More than a year after leaving New York, Kayleigh has travelled well beyond Melbourne, experiencing life in tropical Queensland and on the Gold Coast
The cost of alcohol was another unwelcome surprise.
‘The alcohol here is so expensive. It makes me not want to drink,’ she admitted.
And during a visit to the Gold Coast, she encountered a nightclub security measure she hadn’t experienced back home.
‘[Security guards] would take your picture as you walked into the club with an iPad to just have it documented – who you are to make sure you’re not getting too drunk,’ she explained.
Even everyday products proved unexpectedly different.
Kayleigh was surprised to discover that Tums, the American antacid brand, wasn’t readily available at Chemist Warehouse, and that Australians commonly referred to pharmacies as chemists.
She was also confused by the country’s definition of lemonade.
‘Their Sprite is called lemonade. And I still haven’t figured out how to get actual American lemonade. I don’t really know what the equivalent is,’ she said.
Kayleigh’s early observations capture the adjustments facing those who move Down Under
While Americans generally use the term for a still drink made from lemon juice, water, and sugar, Australians typically associate lemonade with a clear, fizzy soft drink.
Attending concerts also took some getting used to, particularly the way general admission crowds were divided between different entrances.
‘If you’re going to a general admission concert, they’ll have 20 different doors, and your ticket will tell you what door you’re supposed to enter,’ she explained.
‘So it doesn’t really matter what time you show up. A different door might just get let in before you and be in front of you anyway.’
And although she knew Australians drove on the left, Kayleigh hadn’t considered how strange that would make visiting a drive-through.
‘With the cars driving on the other side of the road, the drive-throughs are also opposite,’ she said.
More than a year after leaving New York, Kayleigh has travelled well beyond Melbourne, experiencing life in tropical Queensland and on the Gold Coast.
Her early observations capture the small adjustments facing Americans who move Down Under.
For Australians heading to the US, many of those surprises work in reverse, showing that even two countries with much in common can feel worlds apart.
…Is the grass really greener on the other side?
An Australian nurse recently revealed she was preparing to leave the country for good after deciding New York offers better career opportunities, higher salaries and the lifestyle she has always wanted.
Liv Halliwell, 26, who previously lived in London, is planning to relocate to the United States after falling in love with New York during a three-day visit.
The prospect of earning significantly more money as a nurse is one of her biggest motivations, but there’s another reason she’s particularly excited about leaving Australia: she believes her future partner is waiting for her in America.
‘I truly believe my future soulmate lives there. I do not enjoy dating Australians and I don’t enjoy the culture of our life,’ she said.
Speaking to the Daily Mail, Liv explained that New York appealed to her for several practical reasons, particularly when compared with London.
‘The salary is a big one, it’s a genuine step up,’ she said.
‘I also just wanted a different lifestyle, the skyscraper city that never sleeps energy is such a contrast to London. New York also puts me in a much better position to travel around the Americas, which I’m excited about.’
Liv’s decision began with a short holiday to New York, where she spent just three days exploring the city.
An Australian nurse is preparing to leave the country for good after deciding New York offers the lifestyle she has always wanted
Despite having travelled extensively throughout Europe, she said she had never experienced such an immediate desire to relocate somewhere.
She was particularly drawn to the city’s nightlife, busy streets, restaurants and the constant activity that has made New York one of the world’s most recognisable destinations.
‘I just fell in love. I love city life. I love how bustling it is – the bars, the vibes, the people. I can’t even look at people living there because I get really jealous.’
But unlike Australians who can move to certain countries on working holiday visas and pick up casual jobs, Liv’s move to the US requires considerably more preparation.
‘To become a registered nurse in New York, I need to have my Australian nursing qualifications and registration verified by the relevant US licensing authorities.
‘I then need to meet New York’s specific requirements and pass the NCLEX-RN, the US nursing registration exam.
‘Once my credentials have been assessed and I’ve met all the requirements, I can obtain my New York nursing licence.
‘In terms of nursing, the nurses in America make so much more than we do. Almost double our salary. Even just normal ward nursing because it’s a private system.’
Liv Halliwell, 26, who previously lived in London, is planning to relocate to the United States after falling in love with New York during a three-day visit
Why she prefers dating American men
Beyond her career, Liv believes moving overseas could improve her romantic prospects.
She admitted she hasn’t enjoyed dating Australian men and is looking for a relationship with more romance and traditional gestures.
‘I want something more. I want more chivalry. I want romance, which I have experienced,’ she said.
‘I have dated an American, completely different type of partner. He would open the car door for me, and I’d be shocked, because no Australian man is doing that.
‘This one might also be a controversial take but I also prefer that a lot of Americans tend to have a more provider mindset.
‘I’m going to be a nurse, I don’t expect myself to never work. I want to work. But I prefer dating someone who has that kind of a mindset. I don’t know any Aussies who are like that.’
Her comments reflect a broader frustration expressed by some Australian singles, particularly women who feel the country’s relaxed dating culture can sometimes translate into a lack of effort or romance.
Liv also believes New York would suit her long-term priorities because she doesn’t feel particularly drawn to marriage or motherhood.
‘I feel like New York is probably the perfect place because I feel like a lot of people aren’t doing that there,’ she said.
Beyond her career, Liv believes moving overseas could improve her romantic prospects
‘Australia has a really big issue with tall poppy syndrome’
Liv’s frustration with Australian culture extends beyond dating.
She believes the country’s tendency to cut down people who express big ambitions can make it difficult to feel encouraged when pursuing unconventional goals.
‘We have a really big issue with tall poppy syndrome. I didn’t notice how bad it is until I moved to London.’
Tall poppy syndrome is a term commonly used in Australia (and New Zealand) to describe a social phenomenon where people who achieve notable success, stand out, or show ambition are criticised, resented, or ‘cut down’ by others.
She recalled becoming aware of the difference while dating an American man, who questioned why she was so quick to dismiss ambitious ideas.
‘Why are you just shutting down these ideas I have?’ he’d ask her.
‘What do you mean? I’m just being realistic,’ she’d respond.
Liv explained that she had grown accustomed to a more cautious approach, where enthusiasm was sometimes met with scepticism.
‘I just wasn’t really used to how much Americans hype each other up. You could have an idea and they’re like, “Yeah, you’re so smart, do that”. So it took a long time to get that trait out of my brain.’
And while she will miss her loved ones, she doesn’t feel a strong desire to return permanently.
‘I see myself living there for probably the rest of my life,’ she said.