Irish filmmaker Sinead O’Shea breaks silence on row with Quentin Tarantino’s producer
Documentary maker Sinéad O’Shea is awaiting two New York screenings of her latest film with bated breath, after a dressing down from Quentin Tarantino’s producer at its Sundance premiere earlier this year.
The Navan woman’s latest film, All About The Money, is a profile of James ‘Fergie’ Chambers – an heir to the billionaire Cox Enterprises empire in the USA, who is also a communist activist and donor to left-wing causes including Palestine Action.
Reported to have cashed out $250million (€223million) when he broke away from the family business in 2023, Chambers is currently in a Spanish jail awaiting extradition to the US over allegations of funding Hamas – who he publicly supported after the October 7 attacks.
O’Shea said reaction to her film – which begins on the communist residential collective Chambers funds in Massachusetts and follows him to Tunisia and finally Dublin – has been ‘fairly mixed’.
O’Shea said reaction to her film – which begins on the communist residential collective Chambers funds in Massachusetts and follows him to Tunisia and finally Dublin – has been ‘fairly mixed’
All About The Money, is a profile of James ‘Fergie’ Chambers – an heir to the billionaire Cox Enterprises empire in the USA, who is also a communist activist and donor to leftist causes including Palestine Action
Producer Harvey Weinstein, film critic Elvis Mitchell, director Quentin Tarantino and producer Lawrence Bender
She told the Irish Mail on Sunday: ‘I think people are less interested in it sometimes as a piece of filmmaking or journalism or documentary making, but they’re more asking themselves, “What do I think of Fergie Chambers?”
‘So I think that’s really what guides people’s reactions.’
A Q&A at the Sundance Film Festival in Utah, where the documentary premiered, was dominated by Lawrence Bender, the prolific Hollywood producer with eight Oscars to his name and credits on most Tarantino films.
Jessie made entry in Edna’s diary!
Jessie Buckley ‘said yes straight away’ to narrating Edna O’Brien’s diaries in a 2024 documentary about the author, its director Sinéad O’Shea has recalled.
In O’Shea’s third film, Blue Road: The Edna O’Brien Story, the late writer spoke about her colourful and controversial life in interviews recorded shortly before her death, aged 93.
Jessie Buckley ‘said yes straight away’ to narrating Edna O’Brien’s diaries in a 2024 documentary about the author
And excerpts from the Co. Clare native’s diaries are read in the documentary by Oscar-winning Buckley.
Asked how the Hamnet star became involved, O’Shea told the Irish Mail on Sunday: ‘We had a friend in common, and I thought, because Jessie was someone who’d gone to London at an early age and is having this extraordinary life, maybe she could connect to Edna’s diaries.
‘It was a one-line email, and she said yes straight away.’
In O’Shea’s third film, Blue Road: The Edna O’Brien Story, the late writer spoke about her colourful and controversial life
O’Shea continued that ‘everything that could possibly have gone right on that [documentary] went right’ – partly thanks to the high regard its trailblazing subject is held in.
‘Gabriel Byrne got in touch with me [and ultimately contributed to the film]. A lot of people just gave their time without any persuasion.’
So it was just a great project.’
O’Shea explained: ‘His was the first question, and he just launched into a tirade that went on for about five minutes. “Why did you give this guy a platform? Do you know anything about Zionism? Do you know anything about October 7?”
‘And so the responses have been quite dramatic. Some people really love it, then other people really hate it.’
The writer-director returns to the US for two screenings and Q&As on the 14th and 16th of this month.
‘I don’t know how those New York screenings are going to go at all.
‘It’s my first time back after Sundance presenting the film, and it’s just so hard to tell what the response will be. It’s very divisive,’ she said.
Chambers himself was unhappy with the final cut of the film – which has a rating of 92 per cent from 13 critical reviews on aggregator site Rotten Tomatoes – and even offered O’Shea a ‘life-changing’ sum to pull it before release.
O’Shea explained: ‘I think he felt it was too psychological, and that his political beliefs weren’t clear enough from the film.
‘I think anyone watching the film would be pretty clear on what his political beliefs are.
‘It’s just not an easy sell, and I think there’s so much nervousness in America at the moment about being offensive.
‘Maybe these midterm results [with sweeping Democrat victories this week] might liberate people a bit, but there’s also a lot of budgetary pressure. Netflix has become huge, but now it’s cutting back.
‘There’s these mergers with Paramount and HBO and stuff. So there’s just not as many buyers.
‘But then there’s also the fact that Fergie is really complicated.
‘The reasons we all want to watch are the reasons why buyers are nervous.’
The 41-year-old subject of the documentary, who had moved his family to Ireland before his arrest in Spain, had no issue with the film’s inclusion of discussions around his sexuality and child sexual abuse he alleges suffering while institutionalised as a boy.
O’Shea said his avowed insistence on transparency is ‘something I really like about him’, describing him as ‘shockingly frank at times in this film’.
‘He has this line that rich people hide in discretion, and so he’s trying to break the cycle by doing things differently.
‘So even when he didn’t like the film – and obviously he had the resources to tie me up in the courts for a long time – even if he hadn’t won, it still would have been very difficult.
‘He could have, for example, gone for a super injunction before Sundance, but ultimately he chose not to, and he chose to let the film go ahead.
‘So I think he did stay true ultimately to that idea that he was going to be the one rich person who spoke out.’
O’Shea has not been in touch with Chambers since before his July arrest.
‘I am very conscious that he was supposed to come and join me and do Q&As,’ she said, adding with a laugh: ‘Which would have been intense.’