I defended my ‘hero’ father for 25 years… then I learned the chilling truth of what
By SHANNON CARLIN, U.S. FEATURES WRITER
By the time she turned 20 years old, Ashlee Wlasiuk had spent much of her childhood in courtrooms. The laundry list of reasons for this included family court custody hearings, a close relative’s numerous criminal cases and, most notably, her father’s murder trials; three to be exact.
Her father, Peter Wlasiuk, was found guilty of second-degree murder in the death of his wife, her stepmother Patricia ‘Patty’ Wlasiuk (née Schoonmaker). In each of those trials – the initial one in 2002, and the subsequent retrials in 2008 and 2012 – he was sentenced to 25 years to life.
At just nine years old, she had lost her mother, stepmother and her father, who spent more than two decades in prison and more than two thirds of her life in prison. She felt like she had to fend for herself and two younger half-sisters while her paternal grandparents, her court-appointed legal guardians, focused on getting their son out of prison.
‘Everything always used to revolve around court and proving his innocence,’ she told the Daily Mail.
When Wlasiuk was growing up, her father was her hero. A former mechanic in the army, he was ‘full of life,’ she said. He treated her like a princess, taking her skating at the local roller rink, buying her expensive toys and naming his prized truck after her.
After losing her biological mom, Jackeline ‘Jacki’ Scholte, 35, in a tragic basement apartment fire in 1997, she struggled to connect with her stepmom. Her dad felt like the only true parent she had.
So it was unfathomable that her dad, the person who had always ‘made things special’ for her committed such a heinous act.
Now, Wlasiuk, 34, worries that she may have been wrong about her father her entire life.
When Ashlee Wlasiuk was growing up, her father was her hero
It was unfathomable that her dad, the person who had always ‘made things special’ for Ashlee committed heinous act he had been accused of
Ashlee felt like she had to fend for herself and two younger half-sisters while her paternal grandparents, her court-appointed legal guardians, focused on getting their son out of prison
In her self-published debut memoir, Did You Kill My Mother?, she wrote that ‘too many years have been spent believing the wrong story.’ But what is the wrong story?
That ‘my dad was innocent [of killing my stepmom] the whole time,’ she told the Daily Mail.
Days before her book’s November 10 release, she received a cease-and-desist letter for defamation from her father, 57.
Eight months ago, when Wlasiuk started writing her memoir, an unbelievably heartbreaking and surprisingly sardonic recollection of her traumas stemming from his conviction, she knew he might take legal action.
Her book, which she admitted does not always paint her father in a favorable light, could jeopardize his freedom.
He has a parole hearing set for later this month and if granted, he could be released from prison as early as March 2027.
But that’s why she’s telling her story: Wlasiuk doesn’t believe that her father, who has maintained his innocence, is ready to reenter society.
‘I love him and I don’t want him to be this person, but I don’t think he feels remorse for any bad things that he’s ever done,’ she told the Daily Mail.
‘It just makes me wonder, like, does he have a conscience?’ she said. ‘He won’t even admit to things that I’ve seen [him do] with my own eyes.’
On April 3, 2002, Wlasiuk’s 35-year-old stepmother Patty was found dead in Guilford Lake in the small town of Guilford, New York, in what initially appeared to investigators to be a motor vehicle accident.
That night, according to a four-page statement taken by police, Peter, who said he was sitting in the passenger seat, claimed that Patty was driving when a deer darted into the road, causing her to swerve and plunge the vehicle into the lake.
Peter tried to grab Patty in the water and bring her to the surface, but he lost his grip and couldn’t find her in the dark. After swimming to the shore, he went to a nearby house and let them know that his wife was still in the water, according to the police report.
But the police soon found inconsistencies in Peter’s story, including that despite plunging into the frigid water, which at 30 to 40 degrees Fahrenheit was cold enough to cause hypothermia, he was not exhibiting any signs of the dangerous condition. He was wet, but his body temperature was stable, and there was no indication he’d been submerged underwater for any prolonged period of time.
‘I love him and I don’t want him to be this person, but I don’t think he feels remorse for any bad things that he’s ever done,’ Ashlee told the Daily Mail
During the investigation of the vehicle, the authorities found no signs of damage to the outside of the pickup truck consistent with the crash Peter had described. Both the driver and passenger doors were still locked, and the driver’s side window was open despite Peter having told police he had escaped the vehicle on the passenger side.
Dr James Terzian, the forensic pathologist who performed the autopsy on Patty, discovered that there was bruising across her face, chest and neck that occurred prior to her death.
Terzian also found burdock, a plant with clinging, hook-like burrs, attached to her hair and coat. No such vegetation was found around the area of the accident, according to investigators, but it was found on Peter and Patty’s property. Strands of Patty’s hair were later found stuck to a broken burdock branch in the couple’s yard.
During this time, investigators also discovered that the couple had been in a three-way sexual relationship with Wlasiuk’s babysitter, Joyce Worden, who told them that Patty had recently started drinking again due to the stress of the tryst.
In addition, amid the investigation, a local banker informed authorities that less than nine hours after Patty was declared dead, they received a call from Peter looking to find out how he would go about collecting her insurance policy.
Armed with new information, the police went back to Peter with questions. He then told them a different story; one that the prosecution would claim in court was invented to explain the new evidence the authorities had found.
On the night of the accident, Peter told law enforcement that Patty had been in an alcohol-filled rage over his relationship with Worden and was suicidal. He didn’t initially tell police that she had been drinking because he did not want her to lose her job as a nurse at the local hospital if she survived the crash. Patty was rushed to the hospital, where she was pronounced dead.
Ashlee lost her biological mom, Jackeline ‘Jacki’ Scholte, 35, in a tragic basement apartment fire in 1997
As she struggled to connect with her stepmom, Patty, her dad felt like the only true parent Ashlee had
The drastic shift in Peter’s story, coupled with Patty’s injuries and the discovery of the burdock, led the authorities to believe that Patty’s death was not an accident, but a murder. Her husband was the prime suspect.
During the 2002 trial, prosecutors argued that Peter smothered Patty on their property in Oxford, New York on the night of the accident. He then put her in the bed of his pickup truck and pushed the truck into Guilford Lake. He wanted to rid himself of his wife and collect insurance money to buy a country bar in Binghamton, New York, prosecutors said.
Peter took the stand in his own defense and admitted that his initial story to the police was a lie. Patty was too intoxicated to drive, he told the court, and she lost control of the vehicle. ‘The whole story is I was protecting Patty,’ he said on the witness stand.
Worden would also take the stand on behalf of the defense, testifying that Patty had initiated the three-way arrangement, but she and Peter had taken part in sexual relations without Patty. She also refuted earlier testimony that Peter had abused his wife.
The Daily Mail reached out to Peter Walasiuk’s lawyer for comment. He said he would see if Walasiuk wished to provide a statement, but the Daily Mail did not receive one by publication.
Then just nine years old, Wlasiuk, of course, couldn’t understand the prosecution’s claims. While all of this was happening, she merely thought her dad, a truck driver, was on the road working.
Her paternal grandparents kept that story alive, telling her when a pack of Laffy Taffy or Swedish Fish arrived in the mail that it was a sign that her dad was thinking of her. ‘Little did I know, he’s buying that with his commissary money,’ Wlasiuk said.
It was an elementary school classmate who informed her that her dad had been found guilty of killing her stepmom in January 2003. ‘Not Grandma. Not Grandpa,’ she wrote in her book. ‘A kid at recess.’
Three years later, in 2006, her father was granted a retrial, due to a litany of errors including the admittance of prejudicial evidence, and a teenage Wlasiuk was tasked with helping prove his innocence.
‘He always would say like, “You’re so smart. I want you to become a lawyer,”‘ she told the Daily Mail.
Only later did she realize he wanted her to practice law, she suspects, so that he’d have access to a free attorney.
In 2008, a 14-year-old Wlasiuk took the stand at the local courthouse in Chenango County where she grew up.
Ashlee’s life changed drastically after her father was charged with murder. ‘Everything always used to revolve around court and proving his innocence,’ she told the Daily Mail
She told the Daily Mail that she had been heavily coached by her dad prior to giving her testimony. In her book, she recalled sitting in the basement office of the courthouse, moments before she was set to take the stand, practicing the specific lines she’d been instructed to say.
‘We run it again. Each time, the answers come quicker. Flatter. Less like memories. More like lines,’ she wrote.
‘I don’t know whether I’m remembering it or assembling it in my head,’ she continued. ‘Daddy has told the story enough times that it feels like mine.’
Four years later, when her dad was once again granted another retrial, this time, in part, because he ‘received ineffective counsel’ from his lawyer, according to a New York State Supreme Court memorandum, Wlasiuk encouraged him to take a plea deal.
At the time, she had suspicions that her dad was not as innocent as he claimed. ‘I’m arguing for the early release of a man whom 58 witnesses called “maliciously violent,” she wrote in her book. ‘Hell, I’ve covered the holes his fists left in the drywall.’
Yet, for reasons she ‘can’t seem to justify,’ she wrote, she wanted him home, simply, ‘because he’s my father.’
He chose not to take a plea deal and instead fought it out in court for a third time.
After two and a half days and more than ten hours of deliberation, he was once again found guilty of murder in the second degree. Not in the first degree, which is defined as an intentional killing that is willful and deliberate, ‘because no one believes this could have been a premeditated crime,’ Wlasiuk wrote in her book.
‘He’s dangerous. Reckless, even. But not calculating.’
After his third conviction, Wlasiuk started doing her own research, going through the court documents and in doing so discovered that the story her dad had told her for so long did not line up with the evidence.
For the first time in her life, she couldn’t make excuses for him and his behavior.
‘I’m mad at myself for not opening my eyes to what was going on around me sooner,’ she said.
Yet, somehow, she still felt sorry for him, she recalled, writing: ‘I feel sorry for a third-time convicted murderer.’
Nearly 20 years later, she is still traumatized by the experience of getting up in front of the court during her dad’s second trial.
‘The fear of public speaking combined with the fact that I knew I was lying’ led her to make mistakes in the script she had practiced, she told the Daily Mail.
‘I felt so embarrassed I could feel my skin just getting hot,’ she said. She believes it’s the first time she experienced a panic attack. When she looked over at her dad, ‘he was just stoic, just blank,’ she said.
It made her feel as if she had made a terrible mistake. ‘I just kept telling myself, like, “I messed that up. He’s going away for life. It’s my fault.”‘
In a recent letter to the parole board, she apologized for having lied on the stand as a teen. She realized that she ‘felt so compelled to prove his innocence that I was going to do anything to help do that.’
Since his third conviction, she’s been on ‘this little journey of trying to fact check everything he’s ever said,’ especially as multiple true-crime docuseries including Investigation Discovery’s Reasonable Doubt, Oxygen’s Accident, Suicide or Murder and Forensic Files have come to the same conclusion as those 36 jurors.
That journey has led her to reconnect with her biological mother’s family, who told her they believe that her father may have played a role in her death as well, though they have not provided evidence and he was never charged.
Her birth mother Jacki, who was never married to Peter, died in the basement of her parents’ New Jersey home hours before they were both supposed to go to court over custody of Wlasiuk.
Jacki, who was never married to Peter, died in the basement of her parents’ New Jersey home hours before they were both supposed to go to court over custody of Ashlee
Jacki’s family told Ashlee they believe that her father may have played a role in her mom’s death, though they have not provided evidence and he was never charged
There was never a criminal investigation into Jacki’s death. Authorities at the time ruled that the basement blaze had been sparked by a burning candle. An autopsy revealed she died of smoke inhalation.
The point of her book, Wlasiuk said, is to get her mom’s story back out there, and hopefully get answers to the book’s titular question. ‘It’s not to say that [my father] committed this other crime,’ of killing her biological mother, she explained. ‘It’s just to say, like, it’s a little suspicious.’
Wlasiuk has asked her dad about his whereabouts the morning Jacki died, but she has been unable to get a straight answer – except that he said he wasn’t there the day she died – and doesn’t think she ever will.
Last year, she broke all contact with her father after the birth of her son.
It was having her first child and seeing how little interest he took in him that forced her to question whether he ever really loved her.
‘Do I believe my father loves me? I don’t know anymore,’ she said. ‘I think he only loved me when I was helping him.’
Yet, after all these years, she admitted that deep down she still hopes to find credible evidence that will prove his innocence.
‘It might be Stockholm syndrome,’ she said. ‘But I don’t want him to be who he is.
‘I want him to be a good person. He’s my dad.’