1 of 3,874

Forget Miami…. Two understated Florida towns are America’s hottest luxury property


While America’s luxury housing market is losing some of its sparkle, two understated Florida cities are booming.

The Naples and Sarasota regions are emerging as the country’s hottest high-end property markets, with prices climbing sharply even as they fall across much of the nation.

According to Realtor.com’s October 2026 luxury housing report, the national entry-level threshold for luxury homes, defined as the most expensive 10 percent of listings, fell 2.3 percent year over year to $1,197,014.

But in Naples-Marco Island, that figure surged 9 percent to $3,753,333, making it the strongest-performing luxury market among 43 metropolitan areas studied.

North Port-Bradenton-Sarasota followed with a 7.7 percent jump to $1,796,850.

The data underline the enduring appeal of Florida’s Gulf Coast, where wealthy buyers are snapping up waterfront mansions, pristine beaches and a more relaxed lifestyle without the glitz and relentless pace of Miami.

On Florida’s southwestern coast, Naples has quietly established itself as one of America’s most desirable addresses for the seriously wealthy.

Nicknamed the Paradise Coast, the area is known for its sugar-white beaches, turquoise Gulf waters, championship golf courses and sprawling waterfront estates.

On Florida's southwestern coast, Naples has quietly established itself as one of America's most desirable addresses for the seriously wealthy

On Florida’s southwestern coast, Naples has quietly established itself as one of America’s most desirable addresses for the seriously wealthy

Taylor Canada of Gulf Coast International Properties

Taylor Canada of Gulf Coast International Properties

But local luxury agent Taylor Canada of Gulf Coast International Properties says its transformation has been remarkable.

Born and raised in Naples, Canada remembers when there were barely four buildings on the beach during the 1980s.

Today, grand Mediterranean-inspired homes, luxury developments and high-end shopping dominate, although strict building regulations have helped preserve the area’s more intimate atmosphere.

‘They are really trying to make it not Miami,’ Canada told Realtor.com.

That understated approach extends to its wealthy residents.

‘The wealthy in Palm Beach County are more showy,’ he said. ‘Here, you could be behind a billionaire in the grocery store and never know.’

Canada says records are being broken monthly in certain exclusive and waterfront neighborhoods, with even the previously sluggish luxury condominium market showing signs of recovery.

His clientele includes buyers relocating from expensive states such as New York, Washington and California, alongside existing residents trading up.

He has also noticed a shift towards younger buyers, including people in their 40s with young families, who are prepared to pay a premium for brand-new, fully furnished properties.

But just south of Naples, Marco Island offers a slightly different flavor of luxury.

Kara Heaslip, a broker with John R Wood Christie’s International Real Estate who has lived in Southwest Florida for more than 44 years, says the island has managed to retain a distinctly laid-back character.

‘You’re only a short drive from Naples, yet when you’re on Marco Island, you truly feel like you’re somewhere else,’ she told the Daily Mail.

Nicknamed the Paradise Coast, the Naples area is known for its sugar-white beaches, turquoise Gulf waters, championship golf courses and sprawling waterfront estates

Nicknamed the Paradise Coast, the Naples area is known for its sugar-white beaches, turquoise Gulf waters, championship golf courses and sprawling waterfront estates

Just south of Naples, Marco Island offers a slightly different flavour of luxury with a distinctly laid-back character

Just south of Naples, Marco Island offers a slightly different flavour of luxury with a distinctly laid-back character

Kara Heaslip, a broker with John R. Wood Christie's International Real Estat

Kara Heaslip, a broker with John R. Wood Christie’s International Real Estat

‘It has that resort-style atmosphere where everything just seems to slow down.’

Heaslip says waterfront homes are one of the island’s biggest selling points. Unlike Naples, where waterfront property is more limited, Marco is surrounded by water, offering buyers more opportunities to keep boats directly behind their homes.

‘Having the ability to keep your boat right behind your home and head out to the Gulf without having to navigate a series of bridges is a tremendous advantage,’ she said.

The lifestyle is equally appealing, with residents heading to Tigertail Beach, boating to Keewaydin Island, fishing or enjoying waterfront restaurants such as the Snook Inn and Island Gypsy.

‘It’s really a lifestyle that’s hard to replicate,’ Heaslip added.

The island’s limited supply of land is another attraction, although she cautions that not every property is enjoying the same price growth.

Location, condition and quality of construction are crucial, with buyers increasingly discerning about what they are prepared to pay for.

Heaslip estimates that Marco Island’s median sale price has climbed from approximately $1.075 million in 2021 to around $1.58 million in 2026 – an increase of nearly 47 percent.

However, she warns prospective buyers not to overlook the less glamorous costs of coastal ownership.

Recent hurricanes have caused significant flooding on Marco Island, making insurance, flood zones, maintenance and storm exposure important considerations.

Condominium buyers should also scrutinize building finances, reserve funding and potential special assessments.

Around 120 miles north of Naples, the North Port-Bradenton-Sarasota metropolitan area is experiencing its own luxury property surge.

Its 7.7 percent annual increase in the entry-level luxury threshold was the second-highest nationally, with qualifying properties now starting at approximately $1.8 million.

Luxury homes are also selling faster, moving a median nine days quicker than a year earlier.

The region encompasses desirable coastal communities including Longboat Key and Siesta Key, famous for its powdery white sand made almost entirely of quartz crystals.

Around 120 miles north of Naples, the North Port-Bradenton-Sarasota metropolitan area is experiencing its own luxury property surge

Around 120 miles north of Naples, the North Port-Bradenton-Sarasota metropolitan area is experiencing its own luxury property surge

Sarasota boasts a thriving cultural scene, with attractions including the Ringling art museum, Sarasota Opera, Asolo Repertory Theatre and Marie Selby Botanical Gardens

Sarasota boasts a thriving cultural scene, with attractions including the Ringling art museum, Sarasota Opera, Asolo Repertory Theatre and Marie Selby Botanical Gardens

But Sarasota offers more than beach umbrellas and waterfront mansions.

The city boasts a thriving cultural scene, with attractions including the Ringling art museum, Sarasota Opera, Asolo Repertory Theatre and Marie Selby Botanical Gardens.

Families are also drawn to its schools and sporting facilities, including renowned IMG Academy in Bradenton.

Local luxury broker Joel Schemmel of Douglas Elliman, who has represented properties in the area for 25 years, says the pandemic brought a wave of affluent newcomers – and the momentum has continued.

Specializing in the top one percent of the market, typically homes priced above $4 million, Schemmel says sales at that level have increased approximately 80 percent since last year.

The region was battered by Hurricanes Helene and Milton in 2024, raising concerns about coastal property ownership.

However, Schemmel believes newer construction emerging largely unscathed helped restore confidence.

‘All of those people who were on the fence are like, ‘If I want a house in Florida, why not buy now?” he told Realtor.com.

Buyers are particularly drawn from the New York-New Jersey-Connecticut area, where property prices can be considerably higher.

‘We have a lot more waterfront options, and our price point is in a different zone from the East Coast and Naples,’ he said. ‘The value is here.’

That doesn’t mean Sarasota is short of eye-watering properties. Schemmel currently represents a $38.45 million, 11-bedroom estate on Longboat Key spanning approximately 17,200sq ft.

The wider region is also attracting newcomers beyond the traditional second-home crowd.

Sarasota ranked ninth in PODS’ 2026 list of America’s most popular moving destinations, while LinkedIn placed North Port-Bradenton-Sarasota fourth among its 25 fastest-growing US metropolitan areas for jobs and new talent.

Of course, multimillion-dollar coastal homes come with risks, from hurricane exposure and erosion to potentially hefty insurance bills.

But for affluent buyers, those concerns have not been enough to dampen enthusiasm.

‘Any time I’d think there would be an exodus from those barrier islands, I’d be proven wrong,’ Schemmel said.

And as much of America’s luxury market loses ground, Florida’s quieter Gulf Coast communities are proving that sometimes the biggest property appeal comes without the biggest show of wealth.



Read More

Leave a comment