Stench of hypocrisy is a symptom of the deep malaise that grips Labour: LEO McKINSTRY
For once, the inept local water company is not to blame for the foul stench hanging over the Sussex coast. Instead, the source of the stink lies in the spectacularly hypocritical behaviour of Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner. As more details emerge of her complex property portfolio, she is fast becoming the embodiment of Labour’s double standards and disdain for the public.
So often praised by her supporters for her supposed down-to-earth authenticity, she increasingly comes across as privileged and self–interested, determined to exploit political office for her own ends.
There is a wonderful old saying in the north of England that ‘where there’s muck there’s brass’, meaning that money can be made out of unpleasant tasks. In Rayner’s case, it seems that where there’s brass there’s muck.
Ever since Labour came to office a year ago she has been embroiled in scandals, including claims about Labour peer Lord Alli’s gifts, use of his New York flat and a long-running row over the profits from the sale of her former local authority home in Stockport. But this latest controversy is far more serious.
Angela Rayner has reportedly dodged paying £40,000 in stamp duty on her new Hove flat
Earlier this week, it emerged Rayner, who already has a grace-and-favour apartment in Whitehall and lived in a large house in a leafy part of her constituency of Ashton-under-Lyne, has recently bought an £800,000 seafront flat in the affluent southern coastal town of Hove.
Given that Labour has been waging war against second homeowners on the grounds they worsen housing shortages and price out locals, this revelation is damaging enough. But the controversy has further intensified with the news Rayner may have dodged £40,000 in stamp duty on her new Hove flat by manipulating the designation of her primary residence.
And as this paper reports today, mystery surrounds her use of a trust on the Ashton home which was set up by a law firm whose specialisms then included ‘wealth protection’.
Rayner is immensely proud of the journey she has made from childhood poverty on a council estate to her current political prominence.
But for all her high rank in the party, which enables her to enjoy a salary of £160,000, she knows nothing about wealth creation, having always earned her living from the public purse. Before she entered Parliament in 2015, she worked in the social care sector and was a senior official with the big public sector union Unison.
Rayner’s lack of commercial awareness is mirrored right across the Labour Party, which helps to explain why the Government has so badly mismanaged the economy during its first year in office.
Failing to learn any of the lessons of British history, Sir Keir Starmer and his ministers have adopted the traditional socialist recipe of tax and spend, with predictably dismal results. As welfare bills spiral out of control, with no less than 15 per cent of the working-age population not in jobs and living on benefits, businesses have been clobbered by new burdens, especially the massive hike in National Insurance.
The Deputy Prime Minister’s family home in her constituency of Ashton-under-Lyne
Ms Rayner purchased a luxurious seafront apartment in affluent Hove this year for £800,000 (file image)
She also has access to a grace-and-favour flat in the Old Admiralty Building in Whitehall
In the run up to the General Election, Labour promised a new era of growth, where competence and political stability would enable businesses to flourish. But the exact opposite has happened.
Unemployment, debt and inflation are all on the rise while the public finances are sliding into crisis, reflected in the Treasury’s colossal £50billion black hole. Amid endless screeching U-turns, policy reversals and broken promises, Starmer’s government is setting new records for unpopularity. One poll earlier this month gave the Government a net disapproval rating of minus 56 per cent, the lowest figure in history. Only last week, another put Nigel Farage’s Reform Party 15 points ahead, its biggest ever lead.
The calibre of the Labour frontbrench is deeply unimpressive, which is perhaps why the Prime Minister has recruited his own new economic adviser, Nemat Minouche Shafik, the former deputy governor of the Bank of England. Her arrival looks certain to deepen the discord at the top – just as happened in the late 1980s under Margaret Thatcher, when Nigel Lawson felt his chancellorship was threatened by her adviser Alan Walters.
But Rachel Reeves’s authority at the Treasury was already ebbing, with many questioning where the real power lies – with her or the Left-wing Pensions Minister Torsten Bell who has been hired to dream up radical ways to balance the books in the forthcoming Budget.
If the flurry of possible tax rises that have been briefed to the media in recent weeks (from a ruinous property sales levy to a wealth and mansion tax) is anything to go by, it’s clear that Middle Britain will be footing the bill for Labour’s financial incompetence and disorder.
But good luck selling those tax rises to the country when the Deputy Prime Minister’s example undermines any sense of us all being in it together. Yet, Rayner’s epic hypocrisy is just a symptom of the deep malaise that grips this Government.