1 of 3,895

America’s oldest steakhouse is seeing first expansion in 200 years amid industry revival


Just steps from Wall Street, Delmonico’s has endured a revolving door of owners, standing resilient through even the city’s toughest financial downturns. 

Opened in 1837, it became a staple for high-powered financiers and some of the most influential figures in American history, including Abraham Lincoln and Mark Twain, who gathered there to wind down with friends over boneless ribeye and glasses of wine.

More than a century later, this New York City establishment is planning an expansion into Midtown Manhattan – a notable move at a time when the United States beef industry has been under intense pressure. 

Soaring cattle prices, tariffs and shrinking herds have squeezed restaurant margins and pushed menu prices higher nationwide.

While far removed from the prestige of America’s first fine-dining establishment – as Delmonico’s describes itself – more casual steakhouse chains like LongHorn Steakhouse have seen a surge in customer traffic, reflecting a broader shift in dining habits.

Consumers are increasingly gravitating toward lower-priced, smaller-portion meals. Darden restaurant group’s CEO Rick Cardenas has noted that diners are returning more frequently for budget-friendly options as they look to cut costs or eat more conservatively.

While these chain restaurants are behind most of the growth, upscale brands such as Fleming’s Prime Steakhouse & Wine Bar and the Capital Grille have also grown at a more sluggish pace.

This is due in part to Robert F Kennedy Jr, the Health and Human Services Secretary, who has highlighted beef as a way to meet federal dietary guidelines on increased protein intake. 

Delmonico's is the pinnacle of fine dining for New York's elite financiers on Wall Street and has stood the test of time since opening its doors in 1837

Delmonico’s is the pinnacle of fine dining for New York’s elite financiers on Wall Street and has stood the test of time since opening its doors in 1837

Its blue velvet booths offer a plush haven for influential diners to gather over a glass of wine and a boneless ribeye - and now that signature atmosphere is heading to a newly announced Midtown Manhattan location

Its blue velvet booths offer a plush haven for influential diners to gather over a glass of wine and a boneless ribeye – and now that signature atmosphere is heading to a newly announced Midtown Manhattan location 

Since its inception, the steakhouse has hosted some of America’s most influential figures -including Mark Twain, who celebrated his 70th birthday with close friends at Delmonico’s in 1905

Since its inception, the steakhouse has hosted some of America’s most influential figures -including Mark Twain, who celebrated his 70th birthday with close friends at Delmonico’s in 1905

LongHorn Steakhouse, which has more than 600 locations nationwide, delivered a surge in customer traffic that helped lift Darden’s overall results for the quarter. Sales at restaurants open at least a year rose 4.2 percent, driven by a strong 7.2 percent jump at LongHorn alone. 

That is partly because the chain has not raised menu prices as aggressively as grocery stores, making eating out feel more competitive.

A classic six-ounce filet is around $30 at LongHorn and Outback Steakhouse; meanwhile, Texas Roadhouse offers a filet for $25. Meanwhile, a 10-ounce filet mignon at Delmonico’s is $76 – a sharp uptick in price per ounce. 

Still, Delmonico’s resurgence suggests the fine-dining steakhouse segment may be more resilient than expected, even amid ongoing economic pressures in the beef industry.

This is somewhat because New York City is partial to spending, particularly having a glass with their meal.

But dining at Delmonico’s offers more than just food and drink. Indeed, the restaurant hails many firsts. 

The restaurant claims its head chef, Charles Ranhofer, is the creative mind behind classic 1860s dishes such as Lobster Newberg, Eggs Benedict, and the coveted Baked Alaska.

Created by the Delmonico brothers, the establishment is also credited with popularizing the term ‘restaurant’ and was the first to feature a printed menu and a dedicated wine list. 

Austin Butler at Delmonico's in 2018
Denzel Washington at Delmonico's in 2018

Almost two centuries later, it continues to draw a revolving cast of celebrities, including Austin Butler and Denzel Washington, who attended the Broadway cast of The Iceman Cometh press photocall at Delmonico’s in 2018 

Delmonico's is known for its luxurious cuts of steaks including the boneless ribeye which runs for $89, or if you'd like to go for double the price, the Wagyu for $255

Delmonico’s is known for its luxurious cuts of steaks including the boneless ribeye which runs for $89, or if you’d like to go for double the price, the Wagyu for $255

The restaurant also claims to be the creator of the Baked Alaska, which came on the menu around 1867 to celebrate the US acquisition of Alaska

The restaurant also claims to be the creator of the Baked Alaska, which came on the menu around 1867 to celebrate the US acquisition of Alaska

Founded by the Delmonico brothers, the establishment is credited with popularizing the term “restaurant” and was among the first to introduce a printed menu and a dedicated wine list

Founded by the Delmonico brothers, the establishment is credited with popularizing the term ‘restaurant’ and was among the first to introduce a printed menu and a dedicated wine list

The restaurant claims its head chef, Charles Ranhofer, was the creative force behind iconic 1860s dishes such as Lobster Newberg, Eggs Benedict and the coveted Baked Alaska

The restaurant claims its head chef, Charles Ranhofer, was the creative force behind iconic 1860s dishes such as Lobster Newberg, Eggs Benedict and the coveted Baked Alaska

At the time of its inception, Delmonico’s was a safe haven for New York’s elite – with private dining rooms on the third floor and the city’s largest private wine cellar. 

It also appeared to be a safe haven for accused murderer Harry K. Thaw, the troubled heir of a multimillion-dollar fortune who shot and killed architect Stanford White at the rooftop theatre of Madison Square Garden in front of hundreds in 1906. 

He was seen in a photograph having a full breakfast catered from Delmonico’s in his prison cell which was decked out with a brass bed instead of a cot. 

In the mid 20th century, paparazzi were not to step foot inside and any staff members found speaking to reporters would be fired.

Megastars like Frank Sinatra, Marlene Dietrich and Elvis Presley flocked to the venue for this reason, dining out on oysters Rockefeller and ribeye Bordelaise at tables adorned with Lalique glassware and Cartier cigarette lighters.

But the iconic spot endured years of turmoil, as the post-World War I recession and Prohibition in the United States strangled business, ultimately forcing the Delmonico brothers to close all 10 locations by the early 20th century.

The restaurant reopened and closed multiple times throughout the century and was most recently shuttered in 2020 due to the COVID-19 pandemic. 

It remained closed until a 2023 press release claimed it would reopen in the fall, but this was quickly disputed on Delmonico’s official Instagram.   

At the time of its inception, it served as a safe haven for New York’s elite, featuring private dining rooms on the third floor and the city’s largest private wine cellar

At the time of its inception, it served as a safe haven for New York’s elite, featuring private dining rooms on the third floor and the city’s largest private wine cellar

That included accused murderer Harry K. Thaw, who killed architect Stanford White at Madison Square Garden in 1906, and was later photographed having a Delmonico’s breakfast in his cell

That included accused murderer Harry K. Thaw, who killed architect Stanford White at Madison Square Garden in 1906, and was later photographed having a Delmonico’s breakfast in his cell

The iconic spot endured years of turmoil, with the post-World War I recession and Prohibition strangling business, ultimately forcing the Delmonico brothers to close all ten locations by the early 20th century

The iconic spot endured years of turmoil, with the post-World War I recession and Prohibition strangling business, ultimately forcing the Delmonico brothers to close all ten locations by the early 20th century

The contention built up between the Croatian businessman and the family who said they held the rights to the name, until September 2023 when Dennis Turcinovic and Joseph Licul signed a new lease on the building and reopened it. 

With a fresh slate, Delmonico’s is targeting New York’s finance crowd, opening a new midtown location surrounded by major corporate offices and designed with more private dining rooms for business meetings and events. 

The restaurant hopes to revive the power-lunch scene while adding a modern touch, with executive chef Adam Plitt – formerly of New York’s elite French restaurant Le Bernardin – expanding the menu, including more seafood options. 

The bet comes as New Yorkers continue to spend heavily on dining, with more than $76 billion spent on meals and drinks outside the home in 2023. 

‘As new steakhouses and restaurant concepts continue to open across Midtown, what sets Delmonico’s apart is something few competitors can claim – nearly two centuries of New York culinary history and a deep understanding of the city’s dining culture,’ Turcinovic said in a statement to the Daily Mail.

‘New York doesn’t need another generic steakhouse. Delmonico’s was born here, we’re not a national chain entering the market, we helped define it.’



Read More

Leave a comment