1 of 3,897

STEPHEN DAISLEY: Don’t be angry the SNP gave Mamdani a baby box. Be angry they couldn’t


The baby box is a rare thing about which I have no strong feelings. Some rave about it, others seem offended by the concept.

I’ve never understood either reaction because, whether a desirable or undesirable policy, the one thing it’s not is a transformative policy. It has not shifted our fundamental social or economic conditions in any meaningful way.

The Scottish Government’s decision to send one of these post-natal packages to New York mayor Zohran Mamdani has reignited the Baby Box Wars.

For one side, it is a costly gimmick by ministers desperate for some of Mamdani’s progressive celebrity to rub off on their tired and banal administration. For the other, it is a legitimate means of sharing ideas with a mayor known to be interested in the policy.

It’s a gimmick alright, but costly? Sending a parcel that size to Manhattan will set you back less than £200.

If only we could convince Angus Robertson to travel via FedEx. If it’s just about sharing ideas, they could have conveyed the same information in an email or video. Of course that wouldn’t have brought the SNP some helpful pre-election publicity.

Yet despite my indifference to the policy, I had a visceral reaction to last week’s announcement, to the unspeakable cynicism – the callous cruelty of it.

New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani was sent a baby box

New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani was sent a baby box  

Children's Minister Claire Haughey shows off one of the SNP's baby boxes in 2022

Children’s Minister Claire Haughey shows off one of the SNP’s baby boxes in 2022

 

Because at the very time ministers were posing as supporters of mothers and their children, the mother of Milly Main was still fighting for the truth. For justice.

Milly was just ten in 2017 when she contracted Stenotrophomona at the Royal Hospital for Children, which is based in the grounds of the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital (QEUH).

She was there to receive treatment for cancer, but instead of being extended her young life was cut short.

Her mother Kimberly Darroch spoke again last week about the soul-crushing agony of losing her daughter and the long, painful quest for answers and accountability. She told the news media: ‘To the Scottish Government, I expected more from you. Your inactions have failed us and our children.’

As to why neither John Swinney nor Nicola Sturgeon had met with her, she said: ‘I just think it’s their way, isn’t it? They just hide things or sweep things under the carpet. Them not seeing me is them hiding.’

Kimberly was the picture of dignity. If only the leadership of the Scottish Government or NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde (NHSGGC) could acquit themselves so commendably.

Here was a woman who could use the support of her government, but her government was too busy chasing social media clout among Manhattan liberals.

The Scottish state has its priorities and people like Kimberly and her daughter have always been low down the list, for those determined to rush ahead with the opening of the hospital campus as well as for those who decided a political stunt was the chief concern of government last week.

It is a reminder of the true purpose of the devolved state, whether in the form of the Scottish Government or health boards or other public bodies. The lanyard class isn’t there to serve the interests of the public, it is there to advance its own interests, fads and preferences.

In this culture, ‘targets’ and ‘deliverables’ become more important than what is being delivered and the people who will come into contact with it.

And when it is apparent that the processes or personnel in place have erred gravely, to the degree of profound harm or even the loss of life, the culture is to close ranks, switch off the phones, stick out press statements on Saturday nights, and hide behind an edifice of lawyer-approved obfuscation.

The Scottish Government and public sector think of themselves as terribly compassionate and conscientious, proof of their enlightenment evident in the latest fashionable bandwagon upon which they’ve jumped, ideally something involving the words ‘Nordic’, ‘sustainability’ or ‘the right side of history’.

Milly Main and her mother Kimberly Darroch

Milly Main and her mother Kimberly Darroch

The QEUH is the focus of the current inquiry

The QEUH is the focus of the current inquiry

It would be better all round if policies were designed to improve material circumstances here in Scotland, not to cosplay as whatever Scandi government is currently modish among ministers and civil services.

It would be preferable if the focus were on sustaining outcomes rather than imposing buzzword goals often irrelevant, if not counterproductive, to the task at hand.

It would be ideal if those who rule over us could detach themselves long enough from the right side of history to consider whether they are on the side of the Scottish people.

Of the Queen Elizabeth contaminated water scandal, there is much we still do not know. We will have to wait for Lord Brodie’s findings to learn more.

What we do know is that a number of people are dead, including children. The constabulary is looking into six deaths but that number could increase as the investigation progresses.

We know that after years of denial, spin, and stonewalling, the health board has conceded that water contamination probably did cause bacterial infections in child patients.

We know the Scottish Government is ducking for cover. The First Minister said yesterday that it ‘does look like’ the families of those who died were lied to and that it was ‘quite clear there’s been a cultural problem in NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde’.

It is unfortunate that this clarity has come so very belatedly, after years of SNP ministers rejecting calls to take action to change the personnel and fix the problems within the health board.

Rather more fortunate for the government is the health board’s abrupt clarification of its submission to the Brodie inquiry. 

After its evidence referred to pressure to open the QEUH ‘on time and on budget’, there was speculation as to who might have applied pressure to complete a hospital that opened one month before the 2015 general election.

NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde put out a press release – on the weekend – to assure the media the ‘pressure’ comment had been ‘made in general terms only’ and it ‘should be assumed’ that pressure ‘came from within NHSGGC’.

A sceptic might wonder why a health board would feel compelled to intervene to discourage political rumour-mongering. 

A cynic might say the statement couldn’t have been more transparent if it was written on clingfilm.

From what we know already, we can be confident that patients were let down badly, that some were injured and others lost their lives in connection with a hospital that opened too soon. 

That the state’s response to this scandal was not honesty and transparency but deception and cover-up.

This should outrage us regardless of our politics or beliefs about the NHS.

It is bad enough that anyone, let alone children, could become more ill or die by going into hospital, but it is monstrous that this could be followed by such a prolonged, shameless effort to resist accountability. 

A political or bureaucratic system that is better at protecting itself from scrutiny than it is protecting patients from avoidable death is one that is not fit for purpose.

It is a system that has no place boasting about its munificence towards parents and young children.

It is not an empathetic or generous state that provides supplies for some children if it closes ranks when other children leave hospital in a coffin.

Yes, we should be upset but we should be upset at the right things. Don’t be angry that they gave Mamdani a baby box. Be angry that they couldn’t give Milly Main’s mother the truth.



Read More

Leave a comment